American Oversight Sues DHS Over Unlawful Voter Initiative as Markwayne Mullin Faces Scrutiny
The watchdog wants records on quotas, training, data sources and state-election communications as agencies face questions over their voter-file reviews.
At a glance
- The six FOIA requests were filed September 16.
- The alleged review quota was at least five subjects hourly and 40 daily.
Reviewed November 15, 2026
American Oversight sued the Department of Homeland Security and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services on November 11, 2026, seeking records about the alleged Unlawful Voter Initiative. The suit asks a federal court to require both agencies to expedite six public-records requests and release documents about how officials reviewed voter information.
The requests concern practices that could affect eligible voters if records lead to mistaken flags, as well as state election offices and federal employees involved in reviews. DHS denied expedited processing and claimed an extension; the watchdog says USCIS has not answered its requests and neither agency has produced records.
The filing followed Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin’s Election Day pledge to review voting logs from the prior week’s election for possible noncitizen voting. A separate October 28 case challenges the program on other grounds; the October 28 lawsuit over the voter initiative concerns claims that the effort intimidates voters.
The requests target the initiative’s rules and data pipeline
The six Freedom of Information Act requests were filed September 16. The lawsuit asks the court to order the agencies to process them on an expedited basis and release responsive records.
The requests cover five categories:
- Emails from senior DHS and USCIS officials, including Mullin, Deputy Secretary Troy Edgar, Senior Counselor Heather Honey and Joseph Edlow. Search terms include “unlawful voter,” “voter fraud,” “state voter,” “voter record,” “FDNS enhancement” and “overtime.”
- Training materials for personnel in USCIS’s Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate, including a video shown on or around August 21.
- Records describing any quotas or targets for the number of people officers were expected to review.
- USCIS communications since July 1 with election offices in 19 states and the District of Columbia.
- Information about the sources and types of data officers received, along with any matching or data-mining software used.
The watchdog says it is not seeking voter data itself. It says the requested records could clarify how federal officials investigate alleged noncitizen voting and what protections exist for eligible voters.
Chioma Chukwu, American Oversight’s executive director, said the public should be able to see the operation’s rules and safeguards.
“The public deserves to see the rules, the data, and the quotas behind this operation and know what safeguards are in place to protect eligible voters.”
A whistleblower described rushed reviews and attempts to access state files
A September letter from Sens. Alex Padilla and Chuck Schumer to DHS and USCIS included a whistleblower disclosure about the initiative. The whistleblower alleged that officers in the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate were reassigned to examine data for supposed “unlawful voters.”
The disclosure also alleged that USCIS employees were told to misrepresent themselves to obtain state voter records. American Oversight says advocates warned that such conduct would likely violate relevant state law.
The whistleblower alleged officers had to review at least five subjects per hour and 40 per day, leaving about 12 minutes for each person. The disclosure said the pace could increase errors and that officers did not know where the voter data came from.
Those are allegations in the disclosure, not findings in this FOIA case. Studies have consistently found noncitizen voting to be rare.
The agencies have not produced records
American Oversight says DHS responded on October 17, about a month after the requests were filed. The department denied expedited processing and claimed an extension to respond, and the watchdog says DHS has not communicated with it since.
USCIS had not answered any of the five requests submitted to it, including requests for expedited processing, the group said. Neither agency had released records by the time of the November 11 announcement.
The lawsuit could make the requested records available to election officials and the public if the case results in disclosure. The group says those documents could illuminate the methods used in federal investigations and safeguards against wrongly flagging eligible voters.
Other records describe a wider federal review of voter files
Records obtained by Democracy Forward say Heather Honey obtained 48.4 million records from independent sources, while investigators examined 50.6 million records from the Justice Department. The records also indicate Homeland Security Investigations watched recent primary elections for trends or vulnerabilities that could affect election integrity.
In a separate lawsuit, voting-rights and privacy groups contend DHS holds voter records from at least 47 states, covering many of the nation’s 174 million registered voters. They seek to halt collection and use and have the information deleted. The groups argue the Privacy Act and federal system-of-records notice requirements apply; those claims are separate from the FOIA case.
DHS said its handling of publicly available voter files had been transparent and described its enforcement focus this way:
“DHS has been incredibly transparent about the acquisition and the analysis of publicly available voter files conducted by the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate of USCIS. DHS and DOJ are laser focused on prosecuting and removing aliens who vote and preventing the dilution of the votes of US citizens.”
The Justice Department’s dispute with California provides another example of federal voter-record reviews. The United States filed its complaint against California on October 15, 2026. A federal filing says the government had delivered the state a list of more than 20,000 people it believed were noncitizens registered for a federal election and requested review within 48 hours.
Mullin’s earlier registration claims also drew questions
At a July 17 news conference, Mullin said the department had identified 250,000 noncitizens registered to vote in California, New Jersey, Nevada and Pennsylvania. The figures he gave were 190,832 for California, 35,152 for New Jersey, 15,903 for Nevada and 14,576 for Pennsylvania.
American Oversight said Mullin provided no supporting evidence at the news conference. A White House official said the estimate came from commercial databases. The comparison relied on data without identifiers such as driver’s license or Social Security numbers.
DHS publicly said more than 250,000 noncitizens were “illegally registered to vote.” Mullin’s letters to state officials used the more tentative wording “may be as many as.”
In Nevada, DHS sent officials a smaller list of 185 people it said it had confirmed were not U.S. citizens. Nevada told DHS on September 22 that all 185 were citizens, the watchdog said.
The group also sued over the basis for the four-state estimate. With Campaign Legal Center, it previously sought records on DHS changes to the SAVE system, which draws on federal data to flag possible noncitizens on state voter rolls.
There is no voter filing step identified in this case. Watch for agency responses to the September 16 requests and further developments in the lawsuit.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Consult a qualified immigration attorney about your specific case.