Judge Strikes Down DHS Rule That Would Have Capped F-1 and J-1 Student Stays at Four Years

A federal judge vacated the DHS rule ending duration of status on Nov 16, 2026. F-1 and J-1 students keep D/S and a 60-day grace period. What changes now.

Key Takeaways
  • A federal judge vacated the duration of status rule in full on November 16, 2026, finding it arbitrary and capricious.
  • The rule would have capped F and J admission at 4 years and cut the F-1 grace period from 60 to 30 days.
  • Students need no USCIS filing to extend: schools keep issuing updated Form I-20 and DS-2019 records.

A federal judge in Boston on November 16, 2026 threw out the Department of Homeland Security rule that would have ended “duration of status” for international students, exchange visitors and foreign journalists. U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV granted summary judgment to a coalition of universities, educators and unions and vacated the rule in its entirety, finding it arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act.

The decision means F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors and I-visa media workers stay under the system they have used for decades: admission for as long as they pursue their program and maintain status, with no fixed end date stamped on the Form I-94. The 60-day grace period after a program ends also stays in place. For a full walkthrough of what the rule tried to change, see our explainer on how the DHS fixed-stay rule would have changed F-1 and J-1 visas.

The ruling turns a temporary pause into a final judgment. In September, the same judge postponed the rule one day before it was due to start, a step VisaVerge covered when the court blocked the F-1 admission cap nationwide. That order kept the rule on hold while the case continued. Monday’s decision resolves the case on the merits at the district court level and removes the rule altogether.

The government can still appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit and ask for a stay. As of publication, DHS had not said whether it would.

What the Court Decided

Judge Saylor found that DHS did not properly weigh the rule’s costs against its benefits and did not back up its claims that open-ended stays fueled fraud and security risks. He also faulted the agency for skipping less burdensome options, chiefly making better use of the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), the database schools already use to report each student’s enrollment, program dates and status changes to the government.

The court went further on the rule’s limits on students changing programs, majors or degree levels. Those provisions, the judge held, exceeded what Congress authorized in the F-1 statute. “The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” Saylor wrote.

The vacatur covers every part of the rule: the fixed admission periods, the requirement to apply to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services for more time, and the academic mobility limits. The court denied the government’s cross-motion for summary judgment.

What the Rule Would Have Done

DHS published the final rule in the Federal Register on July 17, 2026, with an effective date of September 15, 2026. It followed a 2025 proposal that VisaVerge reported when DHS first proposed capping student stays. The agency accepted comments for 32 days and received nearly 22,000.

The rule would have replaced open-ended admission with a fixed end date for every F, J and I visa holder. Students who needed more time, because of a research delay, a medical leave or a switch to a longer program, would have had to file Form I-539 with USCIS and wait for a decision instead of getting an updated Form I-20 from their school. USCIS had already rolled out new editions of Forms I-539 and I-765 to prepare for the change.

Vacated rule vs. the rules that apply now
IssueVacated DHS ruleWhat applies now
Length of stay (F and J)Fixed admission of up to 4 years or the program end date, whichever came firstDuration of status: as long as you pursue your program and keep status
Needing more timeFile Form I-539 with USCISSchool issues an updated Form I-20 or DS-2019
Grace period after the program30 days60 days for F-1; 30 days for J-1
English language programsCapped at 24 months plus 30 daysNo fixed cap
Changing program or levelNo change in the first academic year for undergraduates; no second degree at the same or lower levelExisting transfer and program-change rules
I-visa journalistsUp to 240 days, 90 days for certain PRC passport holdersDuration of status for the assignment

Students already in the U.S. would not have kept open-ended status forever. The rule set outer dates for current duration-of-status holders: November 14, 2030 for F-1 students and October 15, 2030 for J-1 exchange visitors. Those deadlines are gone with the rest of the rule.

How the Case Got Here

The lawsuit, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. Department of Homeland Security (No. 1:26-cv-13799), was brought by a coalition that includes NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the Presidents’ Alliance, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, the American Federation of Teachers, the United Auto Workers and the NewsGuild-CWA. The unions joined because many graduate student workers and foreign journalists hold the visas the rule covered.

Duration of status rule: key dates
Jul 17, 2026
DHS publishes the final rule ending duration of status.
Sep 14, 2026
Judge Saylor postpones the rule nationwide, one day before it was due to start.
Sep 15, 2026
Planned effective date passes; the rule never takes effect.
Sep 30, 2026
The government appeals the postponement to the First Circuit.
Nov 13, 2026
The First Circuit holds that appeal in abeyance.
Nov 16, 2026
Summary judgment for the plaintiffs; the rule is vacated in full.

Because of the September postponement, the rule never took effect. No student was ever admitted on a four-year clock under it, and no student had to file Form I-539 to stay enrolled. The government’s appeal of that earlier order had been on hold in the First Circuit since November 13.

What It Means for F-1 and J-1 Students Now

Important Notice
Ignore older advice telling F-1 or J-1 students to file Form I-539 for more time. That step belonged to the vacated rule and never took effect.

For international students and exchange visitors in the U.S., nothing changes from the system they live under today. Their I-94 records continue to read “D/S,” and their school’s designated school official (DSO) or responsible officer (RO) remains the person who extends a program end date.

  • Program extensions: ask your DSO for an updated Form I-20 (F-1) or your RO for an updated DS-2019 (J-1) before your current end date. No USCIS filing is needed.
  • Changing majors or degree levels: the first-year ban and second-degree limits never took effect and are now void. Normal transfer and change-of-level rules apply.
  • After graduation: F-1 students keep the 60-day period to leave, transfer, start a new program or change status.
  • OPT and STEM OPT: work authorization runs on the existing rules. The rule’s plan to tie admission to the EAD end date plus 30 days is gone. See our coverage of how the rule would have treated OPT filers.

Students should still keep their SEVIS records clean. Duration of status depends on maintaining status: full-time enrollment, authorized employment only, and timely reporting of address and program changes. A lapse can end status regardless of how the court case turns out.

How Universities and Unions Reacted

Miriam Feldblum, president and CEO of the Presidents’ Alliance, called the decision “a clear and important victory for international students and scholars.” NAFSA executive director and CEO Fanta Aw said the ruling confirms that duration of status stays in place for students and exchange visitors.

Leaders of the independent-college association in Massachusetts, the AFT and the NewsGuild-CWA also welcomed the decision. Schools had spent the summer preparing advising materials for a system that would have required thousands of students to apply to USCIS mid-program. The ruling lands as new international enrollment fell 15% this fall, according to Institute of International Education data.

DHS had not commented publicly on the ruling as of publication. The administration has defended the rule as a way to curb visa fraud, make sure students leave on time and protect American jobs.

What Happens Next

Analyst Note
An appeal alone does not bring the rule back. Only a stay from the district court or the First Circuit would let DHS enforce it again.

The government has two main options. It can appeal the final judgment to the First Circuit and ask either court to stay the vacatur while the appeal runs, or it can start a new rulemaking that tries to answer the court’s objections. A new rule would need a fresh proposal and comment period, which takes months at minimum. An appeal by itself does not revive the rule; only a stay would.

The ruling’s reasoning will also shape any second attempt. The judge’s finding that the program-change limits conflict with the F-1 statute is a legal holding, not just a defect in DHS’s explanation, so a redrafted rule could not simply re-adopt those limits with a better record.

Students and exchange visitors should take three steps: keep following their DSO or RO’s advice, ignore any outdated guidance that tells them to file Form I-539 for a program extension, and watch for a government appeal or stay request in the coming weeks. VisaVerge will update this story if DHS appeals. For background on the original policy, see how DHS moved to end duration of status for F, J and I visas.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is duration of status still in effect for F-1 students?

Yes. On November 16, 2026, Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV vacated the DHS rule that would have ended duration of status. F-1 students remain admitted for as long as they pursue their program and maintain status, and their I-94 records continue to show D/S.

Did the four-year cap on student visas ever take effect?

No. The rule was due to start on September 15, 2026, but the court postponed it nationwide on September 14. The November 16 ruling then vacated it, so no student was ever admitted on a four-year clock under the rule.

Do F-1 students need to file Form I-539 to extend their program?

No. The Form I-539 requirement was part of the vacated rule. F-1 students extend by getting an updated Form I-20 from their designated school official, and J-1 exchange visitors get an updated DS-2019 from their responsible officer.

What is the grace period for F-1 students after graduation now?

The grace period stays at 60 days for F-1 students. The vacated rule would have cut it to 30 days. J-1 exchange visitors keep their existing 30-day grace period.

Why did the judge strike down the duration of status rule?

The court found the rule arbitrary and capricious. DHS did not properly weigh costs and benefits, did not support its fraud claims, and ignored less burdensome options such as better use of SEVIS. The judge also held the program-change limits exceed the F-1 statute.

Can DHS appeal the duration of status ruling?

Yes. The government can appeal to the First Circuit and ask for a stay. An appeal alone does not revive the rule; only a stay would. DHS could also try a new rulemaking, which requires a new proposal and comment period.

Who sued to stop the DHS duration of status rule?

The case is Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration v. DHS, No. 1:26-cv-13799 in Massachusetts. Plaintiffs include NAFSA, the Presidents’ Alliance, a Massachusetts independent-college association, the AFT, the UAW and the NewsGuild-CWA.

Keep reading

More in F1Visa →

People also ask

Answers from VisaVerge guides
How does the proposed rule change the current duration of status (D/S) policy for F-1 and J-1 holders?

The proposal would replace the long-standing D/S policy with a fixed four-year limit on most international student visas and research scholar stays.

Read: BU Expands Opposition to DHS Four-Year Visa Limit Proposal
What is the new rule regarding F-1 and J-1 visa holders' duration of status?

The DHS Final Rule replaces the long-standing Duration of Status policy with a fixed admission period capped at four years for F-1, J-1, and I visa holders.

Read: DHS Final Rule Ends Duration of Status, Prompting Brain Drain of Foreign Scientists
What are the current duration of status rules for F-1 and J-1 visa holders?

Under the current system, F-1 and J-1 visitors can stay as long as they maintain status—meaning full-time enrollment, valid forms, and clean SEVIS records—without an I-94 end date forcing routine renewals.

Read: U.S. Proposes Fixed Admission Periods for F-1, J-1, I Visas
How long can F-1 and J-1 students stay under the current Duration of Status system?

Under the current system, F-1 and J-1 students can remain in the country as long as they maintain valid documents and follow their program rules.

Read: Trump Proposes Major US Student Visa Reforms for F-1, J-1, M-1
What do you think? 51 reactions
Useful? 100%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Shashank Singh

Shashank Singh reports on India and South Asia immigration for VisaVerge.com, with a strong focus on international students and the Indian diaspora — from F-1 study routes and student safety to news affecting Indians abroad and in the Gulf. He delivers timely, accurate coverage and presents complex developments in an accessible way. Shashank keeps VisaVerge's large South Asian readership at the forefront of the news that matters to them.