India Condemns U.S. Vice President’s H-1B Comments as Deeply Offensive

Article Updates1 update Oct 9, 2026Latest At the ET Startup Awards 2026 in Bengaluru on October 9, 2026, Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal said tighter U.S. H-1B access could be a “big win” for India by keeping skilled professionals in the country and expanding technology work and startups. His remarks followed a separate […]

Article Updates1 update
Oct 9, 2026Latest

At the ET Startup Awards 2026 in Bengaluru on October 9, 2026, Union Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal said tighter U.S. H-1B access could be a “big win” for India by keeping skilled professionals in the country and expanding technology work and startups. His remarks followed a separate U.S. suspension of certain technology companies’ PERM applications on October 8.

  • Goyal pointed to global capability centers and technology operations in Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Pune, Gurugram, Noida, and Mumbai as evidence that more work can be conducted from India.
  • Goyal said remote work had reduced the need for many employees to be physically present in the United States, with only a limited number needing to travel.
  • The October 8 PERM suspension affects part of the employment-based green-card process; India’s Ministry of External Affairs said PERM and H-1B are separate programs and the suspension does not, by itself, affect existing H-1B holders.

India’s Ministry of External Affairs condemned U.S. Vice President JD Vance’s description of H-1B visa holders as “foreign indentured servants,” calling the language “deeply offensive” and “unwarranted” on October 9, 2026. The ministry said the phrase carries painful colonial and historical associations.

The rebuke centered on the wording. India also challenged the implication that skilled foreign professionals should be viewed as a threat to U.S. workers.

“We believe that such descriptions are unwarranted and ignore the fact that Indian professionals in the United States are highly educated and skilled contributors to its economy and innovation ecosystem.”

India Condemns U.S. Vice President’s H-1B Comments as Deeply Offensive
India Condemns U.S. Vice President’s H-1B Comments as Deeply Offensive

The ministry said generations of immigrants, especially Indian professionals, have contributed to U.S. economic growth, enterprise and innovation. It argued that cross-border talent mobility supports both countries through research and job creation. The exchange unfolded as a separate U.S. labor action raised questions about green-card processing.

Vance tied foreign hiring to lower pay and U.S. layoffs

Vance made his remarks on October 8 at a U.S. news conference about visa fraud and foreign-worker hiring. He alleged that companies bring in foreign workers to cut labor costs and replace American employees. He claimed an H-1B employee earns less than a U.S. citizen doing the same job.

“If you are working as an H-1B visa in the United States of America, you’re earning $20,000 less than an American citizen hired in the same position.”

Vance also alleged that workers brought in by foreign outsourcing companies earn $48,000 less than comparable American workers. He framed the practice as benefiting corporations at the expense of U.S. employees.

“You bring in indentured servants from outside the country, you lay off American workers and, if you’re a corporation, you make a ton of money by undercutting the wages of American workers.”

He singled out Microsoft, alleging that the company laid off 6,000 American workers while receiving 6,300 H-1B visas and nearly 3,000 green cards during the preceding year. Vance called the alleged arrangement “a scandalous system.”

The ministry’s response rejected that characterization of Indian professionals. It said their education and skills contribute to the U.S. economy and innovation, and objected to terminology it said carried a painful historical and colonial legacy.

The labor halt targets eight employers, not H-1B status

The U.S. Department of Labor suspended Permanent Labor Certification processing for eight companies. The list includes Microsoft, Adobe, Infosys, Tata Consultancy Services, Wipro, HCL Technologies, Cognizant and Capgemini.

Labor Secretary Keith Sonderling announced the action on October 8, 2026, citing multiple active federal investigations. The processing halt concerns PERM, a step in the employment-based green-card process. It is separate from the H-1B visa program.

That distinction shapes the immediate immigration effect. The Ministry of External Affairs clarified that the action does not, by itself, invalidate existing H-1B visas or change the immigration status of workers or their dependents.

Eligible employees at the named companies could still face delays or other effects in green-card processing. The risk is tied to the path from temporary H-1B employment to permanent residence, particularly when an employee’s green-card route requires PERM.

MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal delivered the clarification. The ministry said the processing halt alone does not end a worker’s current H-1B status. The affected step is the employer’s labor certification process, not the visa framework itself.

India also emphasized the mutual value of mobility between the two countries. It linked that movement of talent to research, innovation and job creation, as the U.S. processing suspension leaves green-card cases at the targeted employers facing possible delays.

Keep reading

More in Green Card →

People also ask

Answers from VisaVerge guides
What did Vice President JD Vance say about the H-1B crackdown?

He framed it as an essential part of true Christian politics and labor dignity.

Read: Why the Trump H-1B Crackdown Matters: Vance's True Christian Politics
How did the U.S. Mission to India respond to the decline in H-1B visas for Indian nationals?

The U.S. Mission to India piloted a domestic renewal option for some H-1B holders, allowing renewal inside the United States rather than requiring travel back to India for stamping.

Read: H-1B, H4, and F-1 Visas to India Fall Over 30% Since 2023
What was Microsoft's response to JD Vance's criticism about the H-1B visa applications and layoffs?

Microsoft denied that its H-1B visa use was linked to layoffs, stating that most of the filings were extensions for existing employees.

Read: Microsoft Denies H-1B Visa Use Linked to Layoffs After JD Vance Criticism
How are US visa policy shifts affecting tech companies from India and China?

Tech companies are shifting hiring to GCCs, offshoring, or domestic recruitment due to higher costs and longer timelines.

Read: Impact of US visa policy shifts on India and China’s tech
Does the recent policy update affect Indian professionals in the H-1B visa program?

Yes, stricter specialty occupation rules may impact the eligibility of some Indian professionals for H-1B visas.

Read: Are Indian H-1B visa holders exempt from US registration rules
What do you think? 0 reactions
Useful? 0%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
IN flag
India
Asia · New Delhi · Passport Rank #125
● Level 2 — Exercise Increased Caution
Shashank Singh

Shashank Singh reports on India and South Asia immigration for VisaVerge.com, with a strong focus on international students and the Indian diaspora — from F-1 study routes and student safety to news affecting Indians abroad and in the Gulf. He delivers timely, accurate coverage and presents complex developments in an accessible way. Shashank keeps VisaVerge's large South Asian readership at the forefront of the news that matters to them.

Jim Grey

Jim Grey serves as Senior Editor at VisaVerge.com, where he leads the site's aviation and air-travel coverage — airlines, airports, TSA rules, and the operational disruptions that affect millions of journeys. With a keen eye for detail and deep knowledge of the travel sector, Jim ensures every report is accurate, timely, and genuinely useful to travelers. His guidance keeps VisaVerge readers informed and prepared from booking to boarding.