Published

Madras High Court Upholds Cancellation of American’s OCI Card Over Missionary Activity

The court said preaching to spread a religion requires prior permission under the Citizenship Act, even when authorities do not allege a conversion.

At a glance

  • The underlying notification is S.O.1050(E), dated March 4, 2021.
  • The show-cause notice was dated September 8, 2025.

Reviewed November 15, 2026

Affects 1 country See full list below

The Madras High Court upheld the cancellation of American citizen John Daniel’s OCI card registration, finding he had preached without the prior permission required for such activity. Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy dismissed Daniel’s writ petition on October 26, 2026.

The ruling leaves Daniel’s cancellation in force and interprets the permission requirement to cover preaching, not only activity resulting in conversion. OCI holders considering specified activities can consult Indian Embassy guidance; the relevant permission may come from the competent authority, an FRRO or an Indian Mission.

Madras High Court Upholds Cancellation of American’s OCI Card Over Missionary Activity
Madras High Court Upholds Cancellation of American’s OCI Card Over Missionary Activity

Daniel had challenged a cancellation order issued by the FRRO in Chennai and dated September 4. The year of that order was not specified. The court also said he could seek a regular visa to visit his mother.

Preaching falls under the permission rule even without conversion

The court relied on Notification S.O.1050(E), dated March 4, 2021, issued under Section 7-B of the Citizenship Act, 1955. The notification requires special permission for missionary, public, mountaineering or journalistic activities by OCI holders.

The judge held that preaching to spread a religion falls within that restriction whether or not it leads to conversion. The order states:

“It is not only for conversion, but even to be a missionary preaching his religion, it is only a prior permission that is mandated”

The court said carrying out the specified activity without permission violates Section 7-B and can attract cancellation under Section 7-D(da). It found Daniel had not obtained the required permission.

The Indian Embassy’s OCI guidance also lists missionary work, mountaineering and journalism as activities requiring prior government permission. The restriction sits alongside the OCI’s multiple-entry lifelong visa, which does not make its holder an Indian citizen.

Government allegations drew on event advertisements and online material

Authorities alleged Daniel held religious meetings, preached in interior villages and encouraged conversions in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh. They also associated him with Laymen’s Evangelical Fellowship International, which they described as functioning like a cult. Daniel denied holding a position in the group and disputed that description.

Daniel denied missionary work and conversion activity. He said his visits were primarily to care for his 92-year-old mother and see family. He had received OCI registration in February 2015, and had spent part of his early life in India, including attending school in Ooty.

A show-cause notice dated September 8, 2025, raised the allegations. The government relied on online material and advertisements, including a poster for Daniel’s speeches at LEF Church in Tenali from January 15, 2017, to January 17, 2017. Other material concerned meetings in Andhra Pradesh from January 14, 2018, to January 16, 2018, and gatherings at Stuartpuram from January 15, 2019, to January 20, 2019.

The court said the material showed repeated addresses to religious congregations and gatherings in Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh, including events advertised to the public. It rejected Daniel’s suggestion that the material was fabricated. The judge also described as “on its face, a lie” Daniel’s assertion that he had visited India only for family purposes.

The judge rejected Daniel’s challenge to the cancellation process

Daniel argued the authorities had not given him documents later produced in court, leaving him unable to respond effectively. He cited Ashok Swain v. Union of India, (2025) 3 HCC (Del) 686, for the argument that a hearing under Section 7-D must include disclosure of supporting material and specific incidents.

His lawyers also challenged the lack of identified dates, locations, alleged converts and evidence that he had compelled or procured conversions. The court accepted that a hearing must be real and effective, but said natural justice “is not a straitjacket formula” and must be applied in light of the facts.

The judge distinguished a specific denial of individual incidents from Daniel’s broad denial of all missionary activity. Because the court found substantial material supporting repeated public addresses, it declined to require a further detailed opportunity to respond. It also said relief under Article 226 is equitable and refused it in the face of what it called a “blatant, bald denial.”

Senior Advocate R Shanmuga Sundaram represented Daniel, assisted by advocates A G Shakeenaa and R Vinayaga Vishnu. Senior Panel Counsel S Padma represented the Central government.

Daniel received registration in 2015; critics questioned the ruling

The court said Daniel had been eligible for OCI registration and that the registration was rightly granted. OCI status provides a multiple-entry lifelong visa, but holders remain foreign nationals and do not have voting rights or specified constitutional-office rights.

John Dayal, spokesperson for the All India Catholic Union, called for a challenge in the Supreme Court and criticised India’s restrictions, contrasting them with US treatment of Hindu priests. Father A. Santhanam, a Tamil Nadu lawyer, said the judgment did not adequately explain the scope of missionary activity or distinguish it from religious activity and conversion.

Daniel can apply for a visa and cardholders can check permission guidance

The judge said Daniel may apply for a regular visa to visit his mother. He may hold meetings or undertake religious activities in India only after receiving the required permission.

OCI holders planning specified activities can check the Indian Embassy’s guidance and seek permission through the competent authority, the FRRO or the Indian Mission concerned. The permission requirement applies to missionary, public, mountaineering and journalistic activities.

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. Consult a qualified immigration attorney about your specific case.

Keep reading

More in Legal →

What to do now

  1. Check Indian Embassy OCI guidance before undertaking specified activities.
  2. Seek requisite permission from the competent authority, FRRO or Indian Mission concerned.
  3. Daniel may apply for a regular visa to visit his mother.

Who this affects

Countries
United States

More on this story

What do you think? 0 reactions
Useful? 0%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Nadia Hassan

Nadia Hassan covers immigration policy and legislation for VisaVerge.com, decoding the bills, executive actions, agency rule changes, and fee structures that reshape the system. With a sharp eye for how Washington's decisions reach ordinary applicants, she translates dense policy into practical context. Nadia's analysis gives readers the "what it means for you" behind every major immigration announcement.