Federal Government Asks Judge to Dismiss Brian José Morales García’s Claims
On November 20, 2026, U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons asked Judge Robert Pitman to dismiss Brian José Morales García's claims against the federal government, which has not yet been ruled on.
At a glance
- The federal government asked on November 20, 2026, to dismiss Morales García's claims.
- The motion is pending; Judge Robert Pitman has not ruled on it.
- The filing does not change any rule readers must follow.
Reviewed November 21, 2026
Follow-up to: Deported US Citizen Brian José Morales García Returns to Texas After Federal Lawsuit
On November 20, 2026, U.S. Attorney Justin R. Simmons, a lawyer representing the federal government, asked U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman to dismiss Brian José Morales García’s claims against the government. The filing also described Morales García as “a dual citizen of the United States and Mexico.”
The motion remains pending. Its filing does not change a rule readers must follow, and the lawsuit is still before the court.
What the government is asking the judge to do
A motion to dismiss is a request for a judge to end some or all claims in a lawsuit. The federal government argues it has immunity in immigration enforcement—legal protection that can limit whether the government may be sued for certain actions. That is the government’s argument; Pitman has not ruled on it.
The filing’s description of Morales García as a dual citizen means it describes him as a citizen of both the United States and Mexico. The lawsuit challenges his detention and deportation, and seeks an unspecified amount of money.
Which agencies and officials are named
The lawsuit names these agencies and offices:
- Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), the federal agency responsible for immigration enforcement.
- The Texas Department of Public Safety (Texas DPS), the state public-safety agency, and the Gillespie County Sheriff’s Office.
The case also includes separate claims against Texas DPS officers and Gillespie County sheriff’s personnel. The federal government’s motion asks the judge to dismiss Morales García’s claims against the federal government.
How the case reached this point
Morales García was born in Denver, grew up in Mexico and later moved to Austin. On April 3, 2026, a Texas DPS trooper stopped a pickup truck near Fredericksburg while Morales García was riding as a passenger with coworkers headed to an air-conditioning installation job. He told the trooper that his birth certificate and Social Security card, which he said could prove his U.S. citizenship, were at his Austin home.
Morales García said he told immigration agents he had entered the United States legally through El Paso and had proof at home. He said agents accused him of lying and threatened that he could go to prison. He was removed to Mexico on April 7, 2026. Before his removal, a U.S. Customs and Border Protection spokesperson said the agency had not arrested a U.S. citizen and that record checks showed Morales García was in the country illegally.
His attorneys filed the federal lawsuit in May 2026. During the litigation, they provided hospital records, witness affidavits and a certified Colorado birth record. Morales García returned to the United States on August 30, 2026, under an agreement with the federal government while the lawsuit continued. After returning to Austin, he said he remained worried that another traffic stop could lead to the same treatment.
In September 2026, attorney Dicky Grigg said the legal team planned to discuss Morales García’s legal options with him and ultimately seek damages—money sought as compensation—from the federal and state governments. Judge Pitman had not ruled on the pending motion as of November 20, 2026.
Keep reading
More in Citizenship →
Citizenship · Nov 21
USCIS Begins 2025 Naturalization Civics Test for N-400 Filings on or After Oct. 20
USCIS now gives the 2025 naturalization civics test to applicants who filed Form N-400 on or after October 20, 2025. Earlier filers stay on the 2008 t…
Citizenship · Nov 21
State Department Opens Online DS-11 Passport Pilot to Two Groups of U.S. Adults
Citizenship · Nov 21
State Department Requires Ssns on DS-11 Passport Applications or Allows an Alternative
Canada · Nov 20
Americans Seeking Canadian Citizenship by Descent Face Waits of Nearly Three Years