Published

DHS and DOJ Finalize Immigration Penalty Rule with Limited Exception for Late Appeals

DHS and DOJ on October 14, 2026, finalized penalty procedures for people who fail to depart, miss voluntary-departure deadlines or are apprehended entering unlawfully; a limited late-appeal exception applies.

At a glance

  • DHS and DOJ finalized the civil penalties rule on October 14, 2026.
  • The final rule took effect October 14, 2026, with no change to penalty amounts.
  • A court stayed some interim-rule penalties issued June 27, 2025 to October 13, 2026.

Reviewed November 22, 2026 Checked against govinfo.gov and the Federal Register

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS), the federal department responsible for homeland security, and the Department of Justice (DOJ), the federal department responsible for enforcing federal law, finalized a rule on civil penalties for certain immigration violations on October 14, 2026. The final rule, a government regulation, took effect that day. It sets procedures for assessing and collecting penalties but does not increase their minimum or maximum amounts.

The rule covers people who willfully fail to leave the United States after a final removal order, miss a voluntary-departure deadline or are apprehended while entering or trying to enter unlawfully. Its main change is a limited exception for some late appeals when documented mail delays were beyond a person’s control.

DHS and DOJ Finalize Immigration Penalty Rule with Limited Exception for Late Appeals
DHS and DOJ Finalize Immigration Penalty Rule with Limited Exception for Late Appeals

Who is covered and what penalties can apply

The final rule, issued by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), DHS and the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), a DOJ office that oversees immigration courts and related review, sets procedures for these civil penalties. Civil penalties are financial penalties imposed by the government rather than criminal sentences. The rule covers:

  • People with a final, executable removal order who willfully fail or refuse to depart, or take certain actions to thwart their departure or removal. A removal order requires a person to leave the United States; an executable order is one that can be carried out. DHS does not issue a failure-to-depart penalty if there is no final executable order, such as when a stay—a legal pause—or qualifying protection permits the person to remain.
  • People who fail to leave within the time in a voluntary-departure order. Voluntary departure is permission to leave the United States by a set deadline instead of being removed. An Immigration Judge or the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA), the body that reviews certain immigration decisions, sets the penalty within the inflation-adjusted range of $1,992 to $9,970. The general default is $3,000 if the order sets no amount.
  • People apprehended while entering or trying to enter the United States unlawfully. Customs and Border Protection (CBP), the agency responsible for border inspections, assesses an unlawful-entry penalty only if it apprehends someone who entered or tried to enter without inspection within the past seven days and before that person has reached their destination.

For willful failure to depart after a final removal order, the maximum penalty is $998 for each day of noncompliance. Unlawful-entry penalties range from $100 to $500 for each entry or attempted entry. DHS’s stated uniform practice is to assess the maximum amount allowed in each case, subject to the applicable statute of limitations, the legal time limit for taking action.

People who present themselves at a port of entry, a designated place to seek entry to the country, to seek asylum or related protection are not subject to penalties under this rule. Asylum is protection that a person may seek in the United States based on persecution or fear of persecution. Unlawful entry for the purpose of seeking asylum does not by itself create an exception to the penalties.

How to appeal a penalty

A person must file a written appeal postmarked within 15 business days after service of the initial penalty decision. An appeal is a request for review of a decision. DHS may serve the decision in person or by regular mail; when mailed, service—the formal delivery of the decision—is complete upon mailing. Without a timely appeal, the initial decision becomes final.

A person may appeal only to DHS, not to the BIA. The initial appeal can consist only of a written notice; written arguments and supporting evidence are not required at that stage. A DHS supervisory officer reviews the appeal de novo, meaning by considering the matter anew, on the written record and must issue a final decision within 45 days. The initial penalty decision is inoperative while a timely appeal is pending. A person may have a lawyer at no expense to the government.

ICE may accept a late appeal as timely only if the person submits a written explanation and any available evidence of delayed or untimely mail delivery, and ICE decides case by case that the delay was beyond the person’s control.

For a failure-to-depart penalty, a person may present evidence on appeal that circumstances beyond their control prevented a willful or voluntary failure to leave. Examples include being unable to obtain travel documents, hospitalization, incarceration or lack of notice.

Lookback periods and other consequences

For a failure-to-depart penalty, DHS applies the inflation-adjusted rate in effect on the date the penalty is assessed, including when the violation happened earlier. The penalty can cover no more than five years before the penalty decision. ICE assesses a voluntary-departure penalty only if the departure period expired within five years before the penalty order. CBP assesses an unlawful-entry penalty only for an apprehension within the preceding five years.

People who fail to comply with a voluntary-departure order are generally ineligible for 10 years to seek cancellation of removal, adjustment of status and certain other forms of relief. Cancellation of removal is a form of relief from removal; adjustment of status is the process of applying to become a lawful permanent resident from within the United States.

The statutes do not give people a right to seek mitigation, or a reduction, of these penalties. DHS may, however, reopen a decision on its own initiative and reduce or rescind a fine. DHS policy is to forgive its failure-to-depart penalties for a non-criminal person who schedules self-departure through the CBP Home app and departs the United States.

How the final rule fits with earlier penalties

DHS and DOJ issued an interim final rule on June 27, 2025, to streamline how civil penalties for the covered violations are assessed; it took effect the same day. An interim final rule is a regulation issued before the agency completes the final rulemaking process. The final rule adopts those procedures, with the change allowing some late appeals when documented mail delays were beyond the person’s control. It also does not expand the violations covered or change the penalties’ minimum or maximum amounts.

A federal district court, a trial-level court in the federal system, stayed specified failure-to-depart penalties issued under the interim rule for people who had a voluntary-departure order or final removal order during the period from June 27, 2025, through October 13, 2026. A stay temporarily puts a legal action or effect on hold. The stay was entered on October 5, 2026. The supplied accounts distinguish those interim-rule penalties from penalties issued under the final rule.

Inflation adjustments and the next review

DOJ said it made no inflation adjustments to its civil money penalties under the Inflation Adjustment Act, the law governing inflation adjustments to federal civil penalties, in 2026. In a notice dated July 10, 2026, DOJ said it would undertake a thorough review of penalties assessed or enforced by its components in 2027. The DOJ notice gives the planned review year as 2027.

Sources

Primary documents and official agency releases referenced in this story.

  1. govinfo.gov
  2. Federal Register

More on this story

What do you think? 0 reactions
Useful? 0%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Nadia Hassan

Nadia Hassan covers immigration policy and legislation for VisaVerge.com, decoding the bills, executive actions, agency rule changes, and fee structures that reshape the system. With a sharp eye for how Washington's decisions reach ordinary applicants, she translates dense policy into practical context. Nadia's analysis gives readers the "what it means for you" behind every major immigration announcement.