Published

J-1 Visa Program Faces Questions Over Worker Protections and Security

A Congressional Research Service review cites exploitation and sensitive-research concerns, while sponsor duties and proposed State Department changes set out the current lines for J-1 participants.

At a glance

  • Summer Work Travel represented 32% of participants from 2015 to 2025.
  • Sponsors must check that host employers will not displace domestic workers before placement.
  • The proposed reinstatement fee after the correction window is $367.

Reviewed November 17, 2026 Checked against Congress.gov

Affects 3 visa types See full list below

The Congressional Research Service identified concerns about J-1 visitor protections, U.S. workers and sensitive research access in a report published November 16, 2026. The review puts the J-1 Visa Program’s employment and security questions in focus for exchange visitors, sponsors, host employers and research institutions.

The report, Exchange Visitor Program: J-1 Visa Overview and Policy Considerations, describes concerns raised over time. It is not an investigation into program-wide violations. Jill H. Wilson authored the report, which says Congress remains interested in whether the program fulfills its intended purposes.

J-1 Visa Program Faces Questions Over Worker Protections and Security
J-1 Visa Program Faces Questions Over Worker Protections and Security

Participation fell to 275,000 in 2025, from about 300,000 in 2024. Summer Work Travel made up 32% of participants from 2015 to 2025; College and University Student accounted for 14%, and Research Scholar 10%.

The concerns span workplace treatment and access to sensitive research

The report describes two different sets of concerns. Some observers argue employment-based exchange categories may disadvantage U.S. workers. Some say employers have a financial incentive to hire J-1 visitors because they do not pay certain payroll taxes for those employees.

Concerns about exploitation have been raised in au pair, Summer Work Travel, intern and trainee programs. National-security concerns focus on exchange visitors who may access sensitive research or technology, including research scholars, professors and university students.

A September 2025 investigation into J-1 workers in New York described allegations at several workplaces. Workers at Kurt Weiss Greenhouses on Long Island allegedly faced long hours, deportation threats, poor housing and unsafe conditions linked to injuries and illness. At Shelter Island café Marie Eiffel, the investigation alleged sexual harassment. Workers at apartment leasing company Aya alleged weekend work without overtime pay, retaliation and conditions unlike those promised. At media company Skytop Strategies, it alleged 12-hour workdays and months of unpaid wages.

The investigation also alleged that sponsors “played down, ignored or dismissed…complaints.” Kurt Weiss Greenhouses’ former director said most employees had positive experiences. Skytop Strategies’ founder called the findings “riddled with inaccuracies.” Studioteka’s chief executive said she had not been told of sexual harassment and disputed wage-theft allegations; sponsor Intrax said it follows all regulations.

Summer Work Travel sponsors must cover wages and offer help

The requirements for Summer Work Travel participants provide a current baseline. Sponsors must explain federal, state and local minimum-wage rules and ensure compensation meets the higher applicable standard, including overtime, or is commensurate with the pay and benefits of similarly situated U.S. workers.

Sponsors must be available to assist participants. Host employers must agree to pay eligible participants overtime as required by law, and sponsors must confirm before placement that employers will not displace domestic U.S. workers at those worksites. Summer Work Travel participants can contact their sponsor for assistance.

State Department plans and separate court action remain distinct

The State Department has published plans for au pair changes addressing childcare hours, compensation, agreements, stronger protections and education options. Separate plans cover camp counselors and college and university students. The au pair rulemaking is the development to watch.

A different State Department proposal, published July 30, would change termination, extensions and reinstatement procedures. It would reduce the correction period for many qualifying SEVIS errors from 120 days to 30 days. After that period, formal reinstatement would require supporting documents and a $367 fee. Unauthorized employment and failure to maintain required insurance would remain ineligible for correction or reinstatement. The proposal would also require some program extensions to be filed 90 days in advance and expand grounds for termination. The State Department has not finalized the proposal.

Separately, a federal district court vacated the DHS fixed-admission rule on November 16, 2026. That rule would have replaced duration of status with fixed admission periods for F, J and I nonimmigrants, but it had not taken effect. An appeal is expected, so the court decision may be temporary.

Some stakeholders and lawmakers also support making the Conrad 30 physician waiver program permanent or expanding it, a separate policy question from the worker-protection and security concerns.

Keep reading

More in F1Visa →

What to do now

  1. Summer Work Travel participants can seek assistance from their sponsor.
  2. Watch the State Department’s planned au pair rulemaking.

Who this affects

Visa types
J-1 F-1 I

Sources

Primary documents and official agency releases referenced in this story.

  1. Official source

More on this story

What do you think? 0 reactions
Useful? 0%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Priya Nair

Priya Nair is VisaVerge.com's Work Visa Correspondent, specializing in employment-based immigration — H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, OPT, and the PERM and green-card process. She breaks down lottery odds, prevailing-wage rules, and employer obligations for the skilled professionals who navigate them every year. Priya's guides help workers and employers make confident, well-informed decisions about building a career in the United States.