Published

ITAT Bangalore Sets Aside NRE Salary Assessment, Orders Review Without TRC

The tribunal set aside Santhoshkumar Vithal Akka’s reassessment and directed a fresh decision based on his passport and bank records.

At a glance

  • Akka’s return for Assessment Year 2016-17 treated him as a non-resident.
  • His South Korea work arrangement ran from September 2014 to June 30, 2016.
  • The Assessing Officer also added a differential interest amount to taxable income.

Reviewed November 18, 2026

The ITAT Bangalore set aside Santhoshkumar Vithal Akka’s reassessment on September 23, 2026, and ordered the tax officer to reconsider whether his overseas salary was taxable in India. The tribunal said missing foreign tax records or a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) could not alone support the assessment.

The decision concerns Akka, a non-resident whose South Korean employment salary was paid in US dollars to an Indian bank account. It does not end his reassessment: the Assessing Officer must issue a fresh decision under the tribunal’s directions.

ITAT Bangalore Sets Aside NRE Salary Assessment, Orders Review Without TRC
ITAT Bangalore Sets Aside NRE Salary Assessment, Orders Review Without TRC

Akka’s return for Assessment Year 2016-17 treated him as a non-resident. He challenged the tax treatment of his overseas earnings, and the tribunal sent the matter back rather than making a final determination of the assessment.

The case now returns to the Assessing Officer. The ruling directs that officer to consider the records Akka provided.

The tax dispute began with overseas salary paid into an Indian account

Akka worked for Ocean Rig UDW Inc at Samsung Heavy Industries’ shipyard in South Korea. His work arrangement ran from September 2014 to June 30, 2016.

He received his salary in US dollars through direct transfers to an Axis Bank account in India. The tribunal later considered those transfers alongside his passport entries.

The tax department reopened the matter and issued a notice under Section 148. During reassessment, Akka submitted bank statements, his passport, salary slips, an income computation and an ICICI Bank interest certificate.

The Assessing Officer included the salary in taxable income and added an amount for differential interest. The Dispute Resolution Panel upheld that approach, relying on the absence of foreign tax returns, proof of tax payments abroad and residency documentation. It also reasoned that payment into an Indian bank account made the salary taxable in India.

Akka appealed the assessment. His appeal challenged the tax treatment of salary earned while working overseas and paid into his Indian account.

Passport and bank records supported Akka’s claim

The tribunal considered Akka’s passport entries evidence of his non-resident status during the relevant period. His bank records supported his account of receiving the salary in US dollars.

It also drew a distinction between payment of tax abroad and whether income is taxable in India. The tribunal said foreign tax payment is not itself a basis for treating income as taxable in India.

The Assessing Officer had not given proper consideration to the passport and bank records, the tribunal said. Akka’s inability to provide other foreign tax documents could not, by itself, dispose of his claim.

The tribunal stated:

“The NRE account also establishes the fact that the assessee (Akka) had received the salary in USD. In such circumstances, the assessment order passed by the AO is not in accordance with the provisions of the Act.”

The reasoning rests on the records in Akka’s case: his passport entries and account statements supported his non-resident status and the currency in which he received his salary. The order does not resolve his reassessment outright.

The Assessing Officer must make a fresh decision from the records

The tribunal set aside the reassessment order and returned the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh adjudication. The officer must assess the case using Akka’s passport entries and account details.

The officer was directed not to make those foreign tax returns, residency documentation or proof of overseas tax payments conditions for considering the claim. The tribunal’s decision therefore changes the basis for the reassessment, while leaving the new decision to the Assessing Officer.

Akka’s reassessment remains to be decided. The next step is the Assessing Officer’s fresh adjudication under the tribunal’s instructions.

Keep reading

More in India →

More on this story

What do you think? 0 reactions
Useful? 0%
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Nadia Hassan

Nadia Hassan covers immigration policy and legislation for VisaVerge.com, decoding the bills, executive actions, agency rule changes, and fee structures that reshape the system. With a sharp eye for how Washington's decisions reach ordinary applicants, she translates dense policy into practical context. Nadia's analysis gives readers the "what it means for you" behind every major immigration announcement.