Judge Finds ICE in Contempt for Re-Detaining Colorado Habeas Petitioners
Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney on November 18, 2026, found ICE officials in contempt for re-detaining a habeas petitioner right after his court-ordered release in Colorado.
At a glance
- Judge Sweeney found ICE officials in contempt on November 18, 2026.
- ICE stopped re-detaining released habeas petitioners in Colorado by November 9.
- The sworn commitment covers habeas petitioners ordered released in the District of Colorado.
Reviewed November 20, 2026 Checked against govinfo.gov
On November 18, 2026, U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney found ICE official Nichole Black and the government respondents in contempt of court—a finding that a person or party disobeyed a court order—for immediately re-detaining Ramon Quintero Alvarez after his court-ordered release. ICE, or U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, is the federal agency that enforces immigration laws. Habeas petitioners are people asking a court to review whether their detention is lawful.
The court found the contempt lasted from October 27 until the practice stopped on November 9. Acting Field Office Director Nathan Rasper gave the court a sworn commitment that ICE would not immediately re-detain habeas petitioners ordered released in the District of Colorado. The judge treated the end of the practice as curing the contempt and took no further action.
Who the court’s commitment covers
The commitment covers habeas petitioners in the District of Colorado who are ordered released by a court. The U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado is the federal trial court for that district. ICE had stopped immediately re-detaining those petitioners by November 9, and Rasper assured the court that the practice would not happen again in the district.
How Alvarez’s case unfolded
- October 20: Judge Sweeney ordered the government to respond to Alvarez’s petition and show cause by October 27. Show cause means explain why the court should not take a specified action. If the government did not meet the deadline, the order required Alvarez’s release within 24 hours after it and a status report within seven days. A status report is an update filed with the court about the case.
- October 27: Rasper testified that he began the immediate-rearrest approach in the District of Colorado and instructed deputy field office directors to review cases subject to release with ICE’s Office of Principal Legal Advisor, ICE’s legal office; check for restrictions on rearrest; and then release and rearrest the person. The government later said Alvarez was released that day and immediately re-detained.
- November 3: The government filed a status report stating that Alvarez had been released on October 27, immediately re-detained, and was still in custody.
- November 4: At a hearing, Assistant Field Office Director Nichole Black testified that she had received an instruction through Deputy Field Office Director George Valdez from Rasper to re-detain habeas petitioners with “some type of criminality.” Black said she knew about the release order and believed that taking Alvarez to a public area before arresting him again complied with it. The court found that the information she relied on about pending criminal charges against Alvarez was inaccurate. The court also said the government had made no effort to show cause why it should not grant Alvarez’s petition and order his release.
Judge Sweeney ordered Alvarez released by 2:00 p.m. that day, with a status report due within an hour of his release, and required the respondents to produce Rasper at a further evidentiary hearing. The November 4 minute entry set that hearing for November 9 at 9:00 a.m. in Courtroom A 702. The number of cases involving immediate re-detention after court-ordered release had grown from approximately 10 to 18.
- November 9: Rasper testified that he had directed the practice to stop and that people rearrested under it would be released. He also assured the court that a habeas petitioner ordered released would not be immediately detained again. Rasper testified that if ICE identified issues with a petitioner’s habeas request, ICE would present them to the court within the seven-day period contemplated by the memorandum of agreement. A memorandum of agreement is a written arrangement between parties; the court noted that the district and the U.S. Attorney’s Office had agreed that habeas releases would be carried out consistently with court orders.
What the court found and what happens to the case
The November 18 contempt order found Black and the government respondents in contempt of the October 20 order for the period from Alvarez’s immediate re-detention on October 27 until the practice ceased on November 9. Civil contempt is a court finding that a party failed to obey an order; it generally requires clear and convincing evidence that a valid order existed, the respondent knew of it, and the respondent disobeyed it.
Because the respondents stopped the practice, the judge declined to take further action. Alvarez had been released, so the court denied his remaining motions as moot—meaning they no longer presented an issue for the court to decide—and directed the clerk to close the case. The case docket and court documents are available online.
Keep reading
More in News →Sources
Primary documents and official agency releases referenced in this story.