Key Takeaways
• DHS is reviewing ‘The American,’ a reality TV pitch featuring immigrants competing for expedited U.S. citizenship.
• DHS and Secretary Noem deny involvement or official support; the proposal remains only a concept under review.
• Public reaction is mostly critical, with concerns about trivializing immigration struggles for entertainment purposes.
The U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is in the early stages of reviewing an unusual pitch for a new reality television show. If this idea moves forward, it could mark a new chapter in how the journey to U.S. citizenship is represented in mainstream media. The proposal, tentatively called The American, suggests that immigrants could compete in televised challenges set across the United States, with the winner gaining expedited citizenship through an on-screen swearing-in ceremony. While this idea has captured the attention of many and stirred up plenty of debate, it’s essential to understand its details, where things stand officially, and what impacts such a show could have on future policy and public opinion.
What Is the Reality TV Citizenship Show and Who Is Involved?
The show’s pitch comes from Rob Worsoff, a television writer and producer best known for his involvement with programs like Duck Dynasty and Dating Naked. Worsoff’s new idea aims to mix the excitement of reality TV with the high stakes of immigration dreams. The plan would involve twelve carefully chosen contestants, each an immigrant, chosen before filming begins. They would start their journey together at Ellis Island—a place that holds deep meaning in the history of immigration to the United States.
From Ellis Island, the group would board “The Citizen Ship,” a playful nod to both sea travel and the goal of citizenship, and set off on a cross-country adventure. Along the way, these individuals would face a variety of themed challenges that would test their skills, endurance, and knowledge.
- Sample Challenges:
- Mining for gold in San Francisco
- Balancing logs in Wisconsin
- Rafting down swift rivers in Colorado
- Building rockets at NASA facilities located in Florida
The competition would build toward a grand finale in Washington, D.C., where the champion would stand on the steps of the Capitol and take the Oath of Allegiance. The prize: fast-tracked U.S. citizenship—something many spend years trying to earn.
As reported by VisaVerge.com, the producers hope to cast high-profile personalities to host, such as Sofia Vergara, Ryan Reynolds, and Mila Kunis, all successful celebrities who are immigrants or naturalized citizens themselves. However, these names are simply suggestions at this stage; none have agreed to participate.
DHS’s Role: Misconceptions, Denials, and How Shows Get Reviewed
A key part of this story centers around the involvement of the DHS. Initial reports, shared widely on social media and some news sites, linked Secretary Kristi Noem directly to the project, even suggesting she was pushing it toward big streaming platforms like Netflix. However, a deeper look at official statements gives a different picture.
Spokespeople for DHS have said in clear terms that Secretary Noem has not shown any support for the show and was not aware of it before the media coverage. According to official sources, the idea is currently just one of many submitted concepts that go through the Department’s regular process for reviewing pitches. These reviews are standard—DHS sometimes checks whether such proposals would be in line with federal law, privacy rules, and the agency’s mission.
In a firm statement, a DHS spokesperson said:
“Noem’s department has strongly denied the report as ‘completely false,’ saying that she has not backed the show and is not even aware of the pitch but acknowledges that it exists.” [2]
This means the show is not moving forward with top-level support or approval. As of now, it’s still just a suggestion.
Public Reaction: Mixed Feelings and Strong Debate
When the reports first came out, people reacted quickly—especially on social media. The idea of turning immigrants’ struggles and hopes into a televised competition has sparked anger and discomfort for many. Some compared the idea to dystopian fiction, saying it reminded them of films and books like The Hunger Games or The Running Man, where people have to “fight” for survival or rewards, all for public amusement.
Many have called the idea “grotesque” and “exploitative,” saying it seems to trivialize the hard experiences immigrants face when trying to build a new life in the United States. For countless families, the path to citizenship is filled with paperwork, long waits, financial stress, and huge emotional costs. Seeing this journey turned into a game show strikes some as disrespectful.
However, others point out that a show like this could also raise awareness of the difficulties of immigration. It might help viewers better understand how much effort it takes to earn U.S. citizenship. Still, the overall mood on social media seems to lean toward criticism, especially until more details emerge.
The Controversy: Turning Immigration into Entertainment
The reality television show concept brings up big questions about what topics are fair game for entertainment and how stories are presented to the public. For many years, American media has told stories of immigrants—from serious documentaries to uplifting films about hope and belonging. But a competition-based show, where only one winner receives citizenship, feels very different.
Some experts, quoted across news sources, raise these concerns:
- Turning real struggles and hopes into a contest might oversimplify or make light of serious issues.
- Granting U.S. citizenship as a prize could send a message that something extremely important can be handed out like a trophy, ignoring the years of waiting and hard work most face.
- There could be risks to privacy or emotional well-being for contestants, especially if their personal stories are told to millions.
People on both sides agree that the path to becoming a U.S. citizen should be respected. The swearing-in ceremony is a meaningful moment for thousands of new Americans each year, often the end of a long road. Turning it into the final round of a TV show is sure to remain a subject of debate.
How Pitch Review Works within DHS
So how does a reality television proposal like The American get reviewed by DHS? Government agencies like DHS sometimes receive pitches from production companies or individuals who want access to federal sites, historic locations, or need permission to film processes such as citizenship ceremonies. The DHS reviews these ideas for legal, ethical, and security risks.
This does not mean that the government supports or approves every idea that’s pitched. Especially with sensitive topics like immigration and citizenship, there are many layers of review to make sure nothing violates people’s rights or the dignity of the process.
For example:
- Filming a real citizenship ceremony, or using the likeness of such ceremonies, might require special permissions.
- Producers must show how they will protect the privacy of all participants.
- Any project that could misrepresent federal agencies is likely to receive extra scrutiny and even rejection.
The public can find more details about DHS’s responsibilities and the naturalization process through their official website. For factual information about becoming a U.S. citizen, including detailed steps and requirements, visit the official U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) citizenship resource page.
The Broader Impact: What If It Happens?
While the show is not approved or supported at high levels now, the idea alone raises some important points for those interested in immigration policy and American culture. If a project like this were to move forward, several things could happen:
For Immigrants
- Some might feel excited to see their stories told on national television. Being selected as a contestant could give immigrants a platform to describe their challenges and dreams.
- Others might worry about being portrayed in an unrealistic or even harmful way. There is a risk that viewers might see these individuals only as competitors, not as people with rich backgrounds and lives.
For the Public and Policy Makers
- A show that spotlights the effort required to gain citizenship could help some viewers understand why so many people want to become Americans.
- At the same time, it could push the idea that only a select few are worthy of citizenship—something very different from the real, step-by-step process handled by DHS and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
For Reality Television and Media
- If approved, the program could set a new trend for mixing high-stake life decisions with reality TV’s format. Similar programs have not been seen before in immigration history.
- Critics warn that this could lead to more “game show” approaches to real-world issues, making it easier for serious topics to be used for entertainment without the needed respect.
Why the Interest Now?
There has always been strong curiosity in the United States about the process of becoming a citizen. Every year, thousands of people take the Oath of Allegiance, joining a long history of newcomers who have made the country more diverse and strong. At the same time, the road to citizenship remains tough for many, with complicated rules, tight limits on numbers, and long waits.
The idea of fast-tracking U.S. citizenship as a game show prize seems bold and, to some, risky. DHS and its partner agencies spend a lot of effort making sure the process is fair, secure, and in line with American values.
Media programs often look for new ways to tell old stories, but there is special pressure when human dignity and legal rights are involved. For producers, this means walking a tightrope between shining a spotlight on important stories and cross the line into what many would see as poor taste.
The Current Status and What Happens Next
At this point, The American remains just a concept. The pitch has been presented and is being reviewed by DHS, using their regular process. There is no sign, as of now, that Secretary Kristi Noem or any high-ranking officials at DHS are supporting the project. They have publicly denied any backing and say the reports are wrong.
No television network, cable channel, or streaming platform, such as Netflix, is attached to the project yet. Casting, production dates, and even the choice of hosts are all just ideas.
Meanwhile, the conversation about what kind of stories America tells—and who gets to tell them—continues. Immigration will almost always be a topic that creates strong opinions on all sides.
In Summary
A reality television show pitching the idea of immigrants competing for U.S. citizenship is under review by DHS, but it has not been approved or backed at this time. The proposal has created a heated public discussion about the line between awareness-building and exploitation.
For those seeking U.S. citizenship, this story is a reminder of the many challenges that shape the journey. For viewers, it opens questions about what should—and should not—be made into entertainment. Both sides highlight just how meaningful the process remains, no matter how it is presented.
For the latest trustworthy information about the real path to becoming a U.S. citizen, or to check the current status of such government policies and programs, visit the official USCIS website, which offers clear guidance and resources.
VisaVerge.com continues to track stories like these, offering expert investigation and updates as new details come to light. The wide discussion sparked by this reality television idea shows just how much immigration, citizenship, and American identity matter to people today. While the pitch may not lead to an actual show anytime soon, it’s sure to shape conversations about immigration for months and years ahead.
Learn Today
DHS (Department of Homeland Security) → The U.S. government agency responsible for immigration enforcement, security, and citizenship-related processes.
Naturalization → The legal process by which a non-citizen becomes a recognized citizen of a country, including rights and responsibilities.
Oath of Allegiance → A formal vow taken during the citizenship ceremony, pledging loyalty to the United States and its Constitution.
Expedited Citizenship → A process or opportunity for gaining citizenship more quickly than standard legal procedures usually allow.
Reality Television → A genre of TV where real people compete or are observed in unscripted situations, often for prizes or recognition.
This Article in a Nutshell
A reality television concept called ‘The American’ proposes immigrants compete in national challenges for expedited U.S. citizenship. While DHS reviews the idea, officials deny any support. The public debate highlights concerns about turning an important life goal into entertainment, reflecting broad questions about immigration, media ethics, and American identity.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• Trump Says Birthright Citizenship is for “Babies of Slaves”
• Supreme Court Stalls on Birthright Citizenship Showdown
• How birthright citizenship shapes legal status in the United States
• Department of Defense loses appeal over expedited citizenship for troops
• Supreme Court scrutinizes limits of nationwide injunctions in birthright citizenship case
