Key Takeaways
• Germany’s citizenship reform on June 27, 2024, allows dual citizenship with the US for naturalized and birthright citizens.
• No retroactive benefits—citizenship lost before June 27, 2024, cannot be restored under the new law.
• Dual citizens must meet all normal requirements and legal obligations in both countries, including tax filing and travel rules.
People often ask what the rules are for maintaining Dual Citizenship between the US 🇺🇸 and Germany 🇩🇪. The laws on this topic saw a big change on June 27, 2024, making it much simpler for many people to keep both nationalities at the same time. This article breaks down the new rules, what they mean for people born with both citizenships, those who get a second citizenship later, and the special requirements and legal obligations involved.
The goal here is to give clear answers using simple words and facts only from the official sources and current law. This helps people with connections to both countries understand what’s allowed, what’s expected, and what might still cause problems.
Historical Background and Reasons for the Law
Until recently, Germany 🇩🇪 did not usually allow its nationals to keep German citizenship if they became a citizen of another country. The common exception was for children born with both citizenships; they were allowed to keep both in many cases. For adults, though, if a German became a US 🇺🇸 citizen through naturalization, they would often lose German status unless they had special approval called a Retention Permit. This made it difficult for people with lives, families, or careers in both countries to keep their ties legal. As a result, many people faced the hard choice to give up one passport to gain another.
On June 27, 2024, Germany 🇩🇪 reformed these rules. Now, people who become citizens of another country, including the US 🇺🇸, do not have to renounce their old citizenship. Similarly, Americans who want to become German citizens don’t have to give up their US status. Lawmakers in Germany said the reason for this change was because modern life often means people have ties, families, and duties in more than one country. Allowing Dual Citizenship can help families stay connected, keep business links smooth, and allow people to move and work more flexibly.
What is Dual Citizenship?
Dual Citizenship means a person is legally recognized as a citizen by two countries at the same time. Each country views the person as its own citizen, which gives that person certain rights and duties. For example, Dual Citizens can often live, work, and vote in both countries. But they also have to follow the laws and responsibilities of both countries, which can include paying taxes and, for some, potential military service.
The New Rules as of June 27, 2024
The key points of the 2024 updates to German 🇩🇪 citizenship law are as follows:
- People who become a German citizen by naturalization do not need to renounce their former nationality, including US 🇺🇸 citizenship.
- Germans who take on another nationality, including US citizenship, don’t lose their German status.
- This rule only applies to decisions (finalized naturalizations or citizenship grants) made after June 27, 2024.
- The change does not apply backward. If someone lost citizenship before this date under previous laws, that loss is final and cannot be undone with the new law.
- No more need for special permits under these new rules.
- Both children and adults benefit.
Germans and Americans can now freely pursue Dual Citizenship without complex applications for exemptions or the fear of suddenly losing one of their nationalities.
For a full explanation direct from the source, you can review the official guidance from the German government.
How Dual Citizenship Applies in Real Life
There are two main ways that people between the US 🇺🇸 and Germany 🇩🇪 end up with Dual Citizenship:
1. By Birthright
This happens when a child is born with a claim to both a US and a German passport. For example:
- A child born on US soil with one German parent and one American parent automatically gets US citizenship by being born in the country and German citizenship through the parent.
- With the new rule, children in this situation do not need to pick one or the other at a certain age. They can keep both for life.
- This is a big relief for parents. Under old rules, children sometimes faced pressure to pick a side. Now, they don’t.
2. Through Naturalization (Becoming a Citizen Later)
An adult might become a Dual Citizen by applying for a second nationality after birth. Until June 27, 2024, this was tricky. For example, a German moving to the US and applying for US citizenship would normally lose German citizenship unless they had special permission ahead of time. Now, both Germans in America and Americans in Germany can become citizens of their new country without giving up their first passport.
Some details to note:
– The process has to finish after June 27, 2024, for the new law to count.
– If someone started the process before, but it concluded after, they gain the benefit of the new law.
– People don’t need to tell the German government at the start of their other citizenship application or request for naturalization permission.
Requirements for Naturalization Involving Dual Citizenship
If you are an American seeking German nationality, or a German hoping to keep your citizenship while getting a US 🇺🇸 passport, you must still meet the standard requirements under each country’s law.
For Germany 🇩🇪:
– Residency in Germany—usually at least five years. It is possible to reduce the time to as little as three years for people who show strong integration, such as very good German skills, active participation in society, or work achievements.
– You must show that you can support yourself and your family without needing help from the government.
– Prove you can speak German at the B1 level, which means basic communication and understanding.
– Pass a naturalization test that covers basic German laws, politics, and society.
– Pay a required application fee.
The full paperwork must be filed in person at the local immigration office in Germany. The office asks for several documents: your passport, residency card, proof of income, language certificates, and a filled application form.
For the US 🇺🇸:
– Requirements are different, but generally include time spent living in the US (usually five years as a permanent resident), passing a basic English and civics test, and showing good moral character.
– Unlike Germany, the US government does not make people renounce other citizenships when becoming a US citizen.
It’s important to note that while Germany 🇩🇪 has changed its law, you must still meet all normal requirements for naturalization. Having a second passport is no longer a problem, but you still must follow the process strictly.
Legal Duties and Rights of Dual Citizens
Having Dual Citizenship with the US 🇺🇸 and Germany 🇩🇪 gives a person special rights, but also double responsibilities. Here are key points to remember:
- Taxes: Both the US and Germany have strict tax rules. The US taxes its citizens no matter where they live, so Dual Citizens abroad must file US tax returns every year, even if they don’t owe anything or live in Germany. Germany’s tax rules depend on where you live and work, and how long you stay.
- Military Service: In rare cases, citizens might be called for military service, depending on age, gender, and current laws in each country. At present, neither country requires compulsory military service, but the laws can change.
- Travel: When entering one of your countries, you must use the passport of that country. For example, fly to the US with your American passport, and enter Germany 🇩🇪 with your German passport.
- Legal Protection: Both countries will treat you as a full citizen when you are on their land. This means all local rights, but also all duties.
There can be cases where laws of one country conflict with the other. For example, being called for jury duty or certain legal obligations. Dual Citizens need to keep up-to-date with both sets of rules.
No Backdating of the Law
The new German 🇩🇪 law is not retroactive. This means if you lost German citizenship under the old rules (before June 27, 2024) because you became American without getting a special Retention Permit, you cannot get your German citizenship back just because of the law change. All past decisions stand. Only citizenship processes completed after June 27, 2024, get the benefit of the new rule. This fact is very important for families hoping to restore earlier lost citizenship—unfortunately, the new law does not offer a fix for these past cases.
Common Misconceptions
There are several common mistakes or misunderstandings around Dual Citizenship, US and Germany 🇩🇪:
- “Dual Citizenship is automatic for everyone.” Not true. To be a Dual Citizen by naturalization, you must still meet all the requirements for both countries.
- “Once you get another country’s passport, you lose the old one.” This was true in Germany for many years, but since June 27, 2024, you no longer lose German citizenship by getting another.
- “You only need to file taxes in the country you live in.” Wrong for the US. All US citizens must file US tax returns, no matter where they live.
- “You can enter both countries with any passport you like.” Both countries want you to use their own passport when entering.
Impact on Immigrants, Families, and Employers
This change to German citizenship law is good news for many groups:
– Immigrants: It allows long-term German residents to get full citizenship without losing their old passport, helping them stay connected to family and open more travel and work options.
– Families: Parents from both countries don’t have to worry about their children having to choose one nationality when they turn 18.
– Employers: Employees who hold both passports can often work and travel more easily for business between the US 🇺🇸 and Germany 🇩🇪 without visa hassles.
– Retirees: People who want to split their retirement between the two countries have more freedom and security.
Analysis from VisaVerge.com suggests that this new, open approach to Dual Citizenship will encourage more people to consider international careers and keep strong links between families in both countries.
What Happens If You Do Not Follow the Law?
Failing to follow the rules as a Dual Citizen can cause issues. Not filing tax returns with the US can lead to heavy fines, or even criminal penalties. If you provide the wrong paperwork when applying for Dual Citizenship in Germany 🇩🇪, your application can be denied or cancelled. Using the wrong passport to enter a country can cause delays or be considered a violation of travel law. Always check for the latest requirements with official sources in both countries.
Ongoing Debates and Future Legislation
The 2024 law change in Germany received wide support, but some critics worry about complex citizenship cases, such as security checks or voting rights. Lawmakers may still revisit small parts of the rule in future years, but at this time, no new bills are being discussed that would undo the big steps made in June 2024. Everyone who qualifies now can enjoy the broader rights granted under the new system.
More Help and Information
This summary provides the main rules and effects of current Dual Citizenship law for the US 🇺🇸 and Germany 🇩🇪. For detailed advice, especially about taxes or special legal problems, readers should check official sources like the Federal Foreign Office of Germany, the US Department of State, or consult with a qualified legal professional.
To sum up, it is now much easier to keep and use both US 🇺🇸 and German 🇩🇪 passports at the same time, after meeting the normal requirements and following each country’s rules. This helps families, workers, and anyone with connections in both places stay legally secure and enjoy the benefits of truly international lives.
Learn Today
Naturalization → The legal process by which a non-citizen acquires citizenship in a country, meeting specific residency and integration requirements.
Retention Permit → A special authorization Germans needed before 2024 to keep citizenship when becoming naturalized in another country, now obsolete.
Dual Citizenship → Holding legal citizenship in two countries simultaneously, granting rights and duties in both.
Birthright Citizenship → Automatic granting of citizenship to a person based on the circumstances of their birth, such as location or parental nationality.
B1 Level (German) → A basic proficiency in the German language, required for naturalization, indicating ability for everyday communication and understanding.
This Article in a Nutshell
On June 27, 2024, Germany transformed its dual citizenship laws, allowing Americans and Germans to keep both passports. No more permits or renunciations are needed. The new law eases immigration, benefiting families, workers, and retirees. Dual citizens still face responsibilities like taxes and proper use of passports when traveling.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• Americans living in Germany must have health insurance under local rules
• Germany targets deportation over pro-Palestinian protest in Berlin
• Friedrich Merz Leads Move to End Germany’s Expedited Citizenship Path
• Germany weighs emergency EU powers to address asylum seekers rise
• EU and US citizens face possible deportation in Germany
