Key Takeaways
• On June 4, 2025, ICE detained Ernesto Manuel-Andres despite his valid Deferred Action and SIJ status.
• A Kentucky juvenile court ruled Ernesto’s return to Guatemala unsafe due to abuse and neglect.
• Ernesto was released on bond of $1,500 after community advocacy and legal efforts.
On June 4, 2025, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detained 18-year-old Ernesto Manuel-Andres at his Bowling Green, Kentucky apartment. This happened even though a Kentucky juvenile court judge had already ruled it was unsafe for Ernesto to return to Guatemala. The case quickly drew attention from the local community, legal advocates, and immigration experts, raising important questions about how federal immigration enforcement interacts with protections for vulnerable youth.
Who is Ernesto Manuel-Andres and Why Was He Detained?
Ernesto Manuel-Andres is a young man from Guatemala who came to the United States 🇺🇸 as an unaccompanied minor. He was placed with family in Kentucky after being released from federal custody, following laws that require children to be placed in the least restrictive environment possible. A Kentucky juvenile court later found that Ernesto had been abandoned, neglected, or abused in Guatemala. The judge decided that sending him back would not be safe or in his best interest.
Because of this, Ernesto qualified for Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) status. This status is meant to protect children who have suffered abuse or neglect in their home countries. It allows them to apply for permanent residency, also known as a green card. However, due to a large backlog in green card applications for SIJ recipients, Ernesto was instead granted Deferred Action by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). Deferred Action is a form of protection from deportation, and in Ernesto’s case, it was valid until 2029.
Despite these protections, ICE detained Ernesto and his father. At the time of his arrest, Ernesto had no criminal record, and his Deferred Action status was still active. This raised immediate concerns about why ICE would detain someone who was not a priority for removal and who had clear legal protections.
How Did the Community and Legal Advocates Respond?
Ernesto’s detention sparked a strong response in Bowling Green. Over 200 people, including the city’s mayor and police chief, gathered at a rally to show their support. Teachers, classmates, and immigrant advocates spoke out, describing Ernesto as a respectful and positive member of the community. Leslie Perkins, a former teacher, said Ernesto’s case was about more than just one person—it was about the kind of democracy and justice the community wanted to uphold.
Community members organized protests, wrote letters, and raised money for Ernesto’s legal defense. A GoFundMe campaign led by immigration advocate Luma Mufleh collected over $30,000 to help pay for his bond and legal fees. The nonprofit Fugees Family and other legal advocates worked tirelessly to secure Ernesto’s release and to highlight the broader issues his case represented.
Legal Background: SIJ Status and Deferred Action
To understand why Ernesto’s detention was so controversial, it’s important to look at the legal protections he had:
- Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) Status: This is a special immigration classification for children who have been abused, abandoned, or neglected. To qualify, a state juvenile court must find that returning the child to their home country is not in their best interest. Once approved, SIJ recipients can apply for a green card. You can read more about SIJ status on the official USCIS page.
-
Deferred Action: When there is a backlog in green card processing, SIJ recipients like Ernesto may be granted Deferred Action. This means the government recognizes they should not be deported and are not a priority for removal. Deferred Action is not permanent status, but it does provide protection from deportation for a set period.
In Ernesto’s case, both the Kentucky juvenile court and the Department of Homeland Security had recognized his need for protection. His Deferred Action was valid until 2029, and he had no criminal history.
What Happened After Ernesto’s Detention?
After being arrested by ICE, Ernesto was first held in local correctional facilities and then transferred to a detention center in Monroe, Louisiana. His detention continued even though he had legal protections and a judge’s ruling in his favor.
On June 23, 2025, a federal immigration judge set Ernesto’s bond at the lowest legal amount—$1,500. The Department of Homeland Security initially appealed this decision, which delayed his release. However, on June 24, 2025, Ernesto was unexpectedly released on bond after DHS either missed the appeal deadline or decided not to pursue it further.
The Bowling Green community celebrated his release the next day at Teranga Academy, where Ernesto had graduated just weeks before his detention. The event was filled with relief and joy, but also with reminders that Ernesto’s legal journey was not over.
Why Did ICE Detain Ernesto Despite His Legal Protections?
ICE and DHS have not given a public explanation for why Ernesto was detained, even though he had Deferred Action and SIJ status. This has led to serious concerns among legal experts and immigrant advocates.
Some possible reasons for such detentions include:
- Miscommunication or lack of coordination between local courts and federal immigration authorities.
- Policy differences between federal agencies and local courts about who should be considered a priority for removal.
- Backlogs and delays in processing green cards for SIJ recipients, which leave many young people in a legal gray area.
As reported by VisaVerge.com, cases like Ernesto’s highlight the need for clearer federal policies to protect immigrant youth who have already been found vulnerable by state courts.
Policy Implications: What Does Ernesto’s Case Mean for Others?
Ernesto’s case is not unique. Many young immigrants with SIJ status face long waits for green cards because of processing backlogs. During this time, they can be left in legal limbo, unsure if their protections will be honored.
Key issues raised by Ernesto’s case include:
- Federal vs. Local Authority: When a state court finds that a child should not be returned to their home country, should federal immigration authorities be able to detain or deport that child anyway?
- Backlogs in SIJ Green Card Processing: The long wait times for green cards mean that many SIJ recipients remain vulnerable to detention or deportation, even after being found eligible for protection.
- Deferred Action is Temporary: While Deferred Action provides some protection, it is not permanent and can be taken away or ignored by federal authorities.
- Community Impact: Detaining young people like Ernesto disrupts families, schools, and communities. It also undermines trust in both the immigration system and local government.
Immigration experts and advocates argue that detaining youth with SIJ status goes against the purpose of child welfare protections. They say it also creates fear and instability in communities with large immigrant populations.
Stakeholder Perspectives: Who is Involved and What Are Their Views?
- U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE): ICE has not explained why Ernesto was detained despite his legal protections.
- Department of Homeland Security (DHS): DHS oversees immigration enforcement and Deferred Action, but has not commented on the specifics of Ernesto’s case.
- Kentucky Juvenile Court: The court found that Ernesto was abandoned, neglected, or abused in Guatemala and should not be sent back.
- Bowling Green Community: Local officials, including the mayor and police chief, have publicly supported Ernesto and called for humane treatment of immigrant youth.
- Legal Advocates and Nonprofits: Groups like Fugees Family and advocates like Luma Mufleh have played a key role in supporting Ernesto and raising awareness about the challenges faced by SIJ recipients.
- Immigrant Rights Community: Many see Ernesto’s case as an example of the broader problems with current immigration enforcement policies.
Recent Developments and Next Steps
Ernesto’s release on bond is a positive step, but it is not the end of his legal journey. His immigration case is still pending, and the backlog in SIJ green card processing means he could wait years before gaining permanent residency.
In the meantime, Ernesto will need continued legal support and community advocacy to ensure his safety and well-being. His case may also lead to calls for policy reforms, such as:
- Clearer rules to prevent the detention of protected youth
- Faster processing of green cards for SIJ recipients
- Better communication between local courts and federal immigration authorities
What Can Immigrant Youth and Their Supporters Do?
If you or someone you know is in a similar situation, here are some steps you can take:
- Know Your Rights: Learn about SIJ status and Deferred Action protections. The USCIS website has official information.
- Seek Legal Help: Work with experienced immigration attorneys or nonprofit organizations that specialize in helping immigrant youth.
- Build Community Support: Local rallies, letter-writing campaigns, and fundraising can make a big difference in raising awareness and supporting legal costs.
- Stay Informed: Follow updates from trusted sources and advocacy groups.
Resources for Further Information
- USCIS Special Immigrant Juvenile Status: Official USCIS SIJ page
- Deferred Action: Information about Deferred Action is available through the Department of Homeland Security.
- Legal Advocacy: Nonprofits like Fugees Family and local legal aid organizations can provide support and guidance.
- Community Support: Schools like Teranga Academy and local immigrant rights groups often organize events and provide resources.
Conclusion: The Broader Impact of Ernesto’s Case
Ernesto Manuel-Andres’ story is about more than just one young man’s struggle. It shows the real-life impact of immigration policies on vulnerable youth, families, and communities. His detention by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, despite clear legal protections and a Kentucky juvenile court ruling, has raised important questions about how federal and local authorities work together—and sometimes against each other.
The strong response from the Bowling Green community, legal advocates, and supporters across the country shows that people care deeply about justice and fairness for immigrant youth. Ernesto’s case may help bring about changes that protect others in similar situations, but for now, he and many like him remain in a state of uncertainty.
As the immigration system continues to face challenges, cases like Ernesto’s remind us of the need for clear, fair, and humane policies that respect the rights and dignity of all people—especially those who have already been found vulnerable by our own courts.
For those seeking more information or needing help, official resources like the USCIS SIJ page and local advocacy groups remain important sources of support and guidance.
Learn Today
Special Immigrant Juvenile (SIJ) Status → A protection for abused or neglected immigrant children allowing green card application after court approval.
Deferred Action → Temporary government protection from deportation granted when permanent status is delayed or pending.
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) → Federal agency responsible for enforcing immigration laws and detaining undocumented individuals.
Green Card → Official permanent residency permit allowing immigrants to live and work legally in the U.S.
Kentucky Juvenile Court → State court that protects minors and decides cases involving abuse, neglect, or abandonment.
This Article in a Nutshell
Ernesto Manuel-Andres, detained by ICE despite court rulings and Deferred Action, highlights conflicts in immigration protections. His case spurred community protests and legal aid, raising urgent questions about youth protections and federal immigration policy inconsistencies affecting vulnerable immigrant minors across the U.S.
— By VisaVerge.com
