Key Takeaways
• Over 4 million U.S. jobs will remain vacant in 2025 even if all unemployed Americans find work.
• Legal immigration reforms could quickly fill workforce gaps in healthcare, construction, agriculture, and transportation.
• Raising visa caps and streamlining visa programs are key recommendations to address the persistent labor shortage.
Executive Summary
The United States 🇺🇸 is facing a major workforce shortage, with millions of job openings and not enough workers to fill them. This problem has serious effects on the economy, making it harder for businesses in healthcare, construction, agriculture, manufacturing, hospitality, and transportation to operate smoothly. Legal immigration is viewed by experts, employers, and analysts as the fastest and most practical way to fix this problem. Adjusting immigration policies to allow more legal immigration can quickly bring needed workers to the country and help the economy grow. This policy brief explains the main causes of the workforce shortage, details how legal immigration can help, explores policy options, and provides recommendations for decision-makers.
Introduction
America’s labor market is in a bind. Even if every unemployed person in the United States 🇺🇸 took up a job tomorrow, there would still be 4 million unfilled positions as of 2025. This glaring workforce shortage has been driving up costs, disrupting industries, and threatening the country’s ability to deliver basic services and goods. One of the main reasons for this shortage is simple: the population is getting older, fewer babies are being born, and the pool of available workers is shrinking. As more Americans retire, fewer workers are stepping in to replace them. Legal immigration reform has emerged as a direct solution that can bring more workers into the country, especially in sectors struggling the most.
Background
Since 2018, the American job market has seen more open jobs than there are available workers. This imbalance is not only due to economic growth but also because of shifting demographics, such as the aging of the “Baby Boomer” generation and lower birth rates among younger Americans. As the native-born workforce grows older and smaller, businesses in key industries find it increasingly hard to hire skilled and unskilled workers.
Construction is a clear example. In 2024, this sector alone was short by more than 500,000 workers. Healthcare, agriculture, manufacturing, hospitality, and transportation are also struggling to find enough workers to keep up with demand. These shortages push up wages in the short term, but they also increase costs for consumers, make products and services less available, and slow down the economy. Without new sources of workers, vital needs like affordable housing, medical care, and food supplies may become even harder to meet.
Legal immigration has always played a vital role in supporting America’s workforce. In fact, foreign-born workers have made up more than half of America’s labor force growth each decade for the last 30 years. As reported by VisaVerge.com, relying on legal immigration is not just a tradition but an economic necessity.
Analysis
Current Situation
The United States 🇺🇸 is relying more than ever before on foreign-born workers to keep its economy running. Several facts illustrate the depth of the current crisis:
- If every unemployed worker in America filled a job, 4 million positions would remain open (FWD.us).
- Construction faces a shortage of over 500,000 workers this year (ABC).
- The shortage is seen in other sectors too: hospitals need nurses, farms need seasonal pickers, factories need machine operators, and hotels need staff (Baker Institute, ABC).
- Shortages lead to higher costs, broken supply chains, and in some cases, the closure of businesses that cannot hire the workers they need (CSIS).
Demographic change is a big reason for this shortage. The share of seniors is growing, while families are having fewer children. More people are retiring, and there simply are not enough young people to replace them. The domestic worker pool is shrinking, not growing.
Legal immigration is a proven way to fill these gaps. Every decade for the past 30 years, immigrants have accounted for over half of the country’s new workers. Without them, the workforce would not be able to keep up with demand. According to the Center for Strategic and International Studies, “Labor shortages will ultimately affect the affordability of American necessities, including housing, medical care, and groceries.”
Implications
A shrinking labor pool affects more than just business owners. Shortages cause:
- Higher prices for everyday goods as companies scramble to hire at any cost
- Delays in housing construction, making it harder for families to find affordable homes
- Longer wait times at hospitals and clinics
- Supply disruptions that may lead to empty shelves or poor service
- Lower U.S. economic growth
The ripple effects are felt by almost everyone—consumers who pay higher prices, patients who wait longer for care, and companies that lose the ability to grow.
The Role of Legal Immigration
Legal immigration is not simply about filling jobs; it also strengthens the economy, contributes to tax revenue, and brings new skills and ideas. Analysts and business groups agree that updating immigration laws is one of the fastest ways to ease the workforce shortage.
Data shows that immigrants help by:
- Quickly providing workers for industries most in need
- Helping to keep inflation in check by reducing pressure on wages
- Making sure companies stay competitive against overseas rivals
- Offseting the effects of an older population and fewer births
In short, immigrants make it possible for the United States 🇺🇸 to fill open jobs, which helps everyone in the country.
Policy Options
Several policy paths could help boost legal immigration and address the workforce shortage. These options are not only about bringing in more workers but also about making the process smoother, fairer, and easier for employers.
- Expand and Reform Visa Programs
- Raise the caps on key work visas: For example, the H-2B visa—used to bring in non-agricultural workers—currently has a cap of 66,000 per year, which does not come close to meeting demand. Raising these limits would align visa numbers with the real needs of the economy.
- Create new, market-driven visa categories: Some proposals, like the Essential Workers for Economic Advancement Act, would allow more flexibility by adjusting the number of visas based on actual labor shortages in the country.
- Modernize professional visa lists: Visa categories like the TN visa for skilled workers from Canada 🇨🇦 and Mexico 🇲🇽 are based on outdated job lists. Updating these lists would unlock more talent for sectors in need.
- Streamline visa processes: Reducing paperwork and delays would make it easier for employers to hire the foreign talent they need quickly.
- Create Pathways to Permanent Legal Status
- Expand programs like DACA: Restoring and expanding protections for undocumented youth (DACA) would ensure that America benefits from skills and training put into young people raised in the United States 🇺🇸.
- Provide clear routes to citizenship: Creating paths to legal permanent status for long-standing, law-abiding immigrants would bring them fully into the formal workforce, boosting their ability to contribute.
- Recapture unused green cards: Many green cards go unused every year due to backlogs; issuing these cards now would help meet urgent workforce needs and support GDP.
- Strengthen Worker Protections and Support
- Enforce labor protections: Making sure immigrants are not taken advantage of by enforcing anti-discrimination and wage laws protects all workers, not just newcomers.
- Provide support services: Offering English classes and legal assistance ensures that immigrants contribute fully and quickly adapt to American life.
- Improve employment verification: Upgrading systems like E-Verify to be more reliable and fair would support employers in hiring a legal workforce and reduce confusion (see more about E-Verify from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services official page).
Evaluation of Policy Options
Each of these ideas has benefits and challenges.
Expanding Visa Caps and Creating New Programs
Pros:
– Directly targets workforce shortages
– Flexible and responsive to changing needs
– Helps businesses quickly fill open positions
Cons:
– May require legislative action and take time to implement
– May face political opposition
Providing Pathways to Legal Status
Pros:
– Allows immigrants already contributing to society to reach their full potential
– Reduces the “shadow economy” and increases tax revenue
– Addresses humanitarian concerns, especially for families and young people
Cons:
– May be controversial for some policymakers
– Requires careful design to prevent abuse
Strengthening Worker Protections and Support
Pros:
– Ensures fair treatment for all workers and levels the playing field
– Reduces exploitation and increases public trust in immigration policies
– Supports immigrants in adapting and succeeding
Cons:
– Costs money to set up and run support programs
– May require additional government resources
Recommendations
The United States 🇺🇸 should urgently strengthen its legal immigration system to address the workforce shortage. The following steps are recommended:
- Raise visa caps and create market-driven visa categories, especially for sectors facing the greatest shortages.
- Restore and expand programs that allow young, undocumented people who grew up in America—such as DACA—to continue working legally and contributing to the economy.
- Establish transparent and fair pathways to permanent legal status for law-abiding immigrants residing in the country for many years.
- Recapture unused green cards to clear backlogs and help the economy tap into this unused talent pool.
- Improve and strictly enforce anti-discrimination and fair wage laws to protect all workers.
- Provide targeted support, including English classes and legal help, to assist immigrants in adapting and contributing quickly.
- Modernize and simplify the employment verification process to give employers confidence that they are following the law and hiring legally.
Supporting these changes are reports from leading policy think tanks, such as the Migration Policy Institute and CSIS, which show that legal immigration reform could boost economic growth, reduce shortages, and improve America’s global competitiveness.
Case Study: Construction Sector
The construction industry offers a clear case for action. With more than 500,000 open jobs, projects slow or stall due to a lack of workers. By adjusting legal immigration policy—raising visa caps and improving processes—employers could fill these jobs, keep housing affordable, and deliver needed infrastructure.
Addressing Counterarguments
Some argue that bringing in more workers could lower wages for existing employees or take jobs from Americans. However, current shortages are so severe that most employers simply cannot fill positions—even when offering higher pay. Many jobs remain unfilled despite strong demand for workers. Additionally, immigrants often take positions in sectors that Americans are unwilling or unable to fill, especially in agriculture, healthcare support, and hospitality. Historical and current data both suggest that legal immigration, when matched to labor needs, does not harm existing American workers but rather supports the entire economy.
Summary and Call to Action
America is at a crossroads. Fixing legal immigration is not just about helping newcomers; it is about securing the country’s own future. The workforce shortage threatens the economy, business growth, and the basic needs of families across the nation. By taking action now to improve legal immigration pathways, the United States 🇺🇸 can close its labor gap, drive economic growth, and maintain its position as a global leader. Policymakers must act to modernize immigration laws so that they work for everyone. For those interested in learning more about employment-based immigration and worker verification, please visit the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services for official guidance and forms.
References
- https://www.fwd.us/news/immigration-labor-shortages/
- https://www.bakerinstitute.org/research/leverage-immigration-address-us-labor-shortages
- https://www.csis.org/analysis/immigration-policy-solutions-shortages-critical-sectors-us-economy
- https://www.migrationpolicy.org/programs/nciip-employment-and-workforce
- https://www.abc.org/Politics-Policy/Priority-Issue-Briefs/PIB-Blog/immigration-reform
Learn Today
Visa Cap → A government-set annual limit on the number of visas issued for a specific immigrant or nonimmigrant visa category.
DACA → Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, a program protecting eligible undocumented youth from deportation and allowing them work permits in the U.S.
Green Card → The common name for a U.S. Permanent Resident Card, granting lawful permanent residence and work authorization.
Workforce Shortage → A situation where available jobs outnumber the individuals willing or able to fill them.
E-Verify → An online system used by U.S. employers to confirm the identity and employment eligibility of newly hired workers.
This Article in a Nutshell
America faces a critical workforce shortage, leaving millions of essential jobs unfilled. Legal immigration offers a proven, immediate solution to this crisis. Streamlining and expanding visa programs, while supporting worker protections, can boost the U.S. economy, lower inflation, and maintain competitiveness. Action is urgent to secure future prosperity.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• IATA Supercharges Saudi Arabia’s Aviation Workforce Boom
• Farm Workforce Modernization Act reintroduced with Dan Newhouse backing
• Newhouse joins push to revive Farm Workforce Modernization Act
• Religious Workforce Protection Act Gets Top Bishops’ Push
• Immigration’s Quiet Role in Strengthening the Healthcare Workforce
