Just Released
📅 November 2025

Visa Bulletin is Out!

Check your priority dates and filing information now

View Details →
Spanish
VisaVerge official logo in Light white color VisaVerge official logo in Light white color
  • Home
  • Airlines
  • H1B
  • Immigration
    • Knowledge
    • Questions
    • Documentation
  • News
  • Visa
    • Canada
    • F1Visa
    • Passport
    • Green Card
    • H1B
    • OPT
    • PERM
    • Travel
    • Travel Requirements
    • Visa Requirements
  • USCIS
  • Questions
    • Australia Immigration
    • Green Card
    • H1B
    • Immigration
    • Passport
    • PERM
    • UK Immigration
    • USCIS
    • Legal
    • India
    • NRI
  • Guides
    • Taxes
    • Legal
  • Tools
    • H-1B Maxout Calculator Online
    • REAL ID Requirements Checker tool
    • ROTH IRA Calculator Online
    • TSA Acceptable ID Checker Online Tool
    • H-1B Registration Checklist
    • Schengen Short-Stay Visa Calculator
    • H-1B Cost Calculator Online
    • USA Merit Based Points Calculator – Proposed
    • Canada Express Entry Points Calculator
    • New Zealand’s Skilled Migrant Points Calculator
    • Resources Hub
    • Visa Photo Requirements Checker Online
    • I-94 Expiration Calculator Online
    • CSPA Age-Out Calculator Online
    • OPT Timeline Calculator Online
    • B1/B2 Tourist Visa Stay Calculator online
  • Schengen
VisaVergeVisaVerge
Search
Follow US
  • Home
  • Airlines
  • H1B
  • Immigration
  • News
  • Visa
  • USCIS
  • Questions
  • Guides
  • Tools
  • Schengen
© 2025 VisaVerge Network. All Rights Reserved.
Citizenship

Israelis Back Palestinian Green Card Holder Detained Amid Citizenship Interview Controversy

Mohsen Mahdawi was detained by ICE during a USCIS interview on April 14, 2025, using a rare Secretary of State foreign-policy authority. A parallel case, Mahmoud Khalil, faces deportation after a judge cited the same claim. Lawyers argue these actions punish speech, lack transparency, and create chilling effects for Palestinian green card holders while courts and advocates seek review.

Last updated: August 28, 2025 1:30 pm
SHARE
VisaVerge.com
📋
Key takeaways
Mohsen Mahdawi was detained by ICE at a USCIS naturalization interview in Colchester on April 14, 2025.
Government cites a rare Secretary of State foreign-policy authority, attributed to Marco Rubio, to justify removals.
Mahmoud Khalil faces deportation after a Louisiana judge credited the Secretary’s claim despite limited evidence review.

(COLCHESTER) On April 14, 2025, Mohsen K. Mahdawi, a Palestinian student and protest organizer at Columbia University, arrived at the local U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) office for a naturalization interview after 10 years in the United States 🇺🇸. He was detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) inside the building and placed in deportation proceedings. His attorney, Luna Droubi, said he was “unlawfully detained… for no reason other than his Palestinian identity.” According to case filings, the government is relying on a rarely used foreign policy authority, attributed to Secretary of State Marco Rubio, to justify his removal.

Mahdawi’s arrest inside a USCIS site in Colchester, Vermont, drew immediate attention from campus circles and beyond. Students and faculty who followed his leadership in protests against Israel’s war in Gaza say the timing sends a message that political speech may trigger immigration penalties. The response reached across borders: Israelis who oppose the Gaza campaign joined Palestinians and human rights groups in calling for his release, viewing the case as a test of free expression for noncitizens.

Israelis Back Palestinian Green Card Holder Detained Amid Citizenship Interview Controversy
Israelis Back Palestinian Green Card Holder Detained Amid Citizenship Interview Controversy

Mahdawi’s lawyers filed a habeas corpus petition challenging the detention, arguing violations of statutory and due process rights and stating the government is punishing protected speech about Palestine and Israel. The petition contests the legal basis for holding a lawful permanent resident who appeared for a routine step in the citizenship process. As of August 28, 2025, the case remains active, with supporters pressing for his parole and a full hearing on the merits.

Parallel Case: Mahmoud Khalil

A second case has unfolded along similar lines. Mahmoud Khalil, also a Palestinian activist and green card holder, was arrested by ICE in March 2025 in New York City. He is married to a U.S. citizen and helped organize pro-Palestinian demonstrations as a student at Columbia University.

Key developments in Khalil’s case:
– In May 2025, an immigration judge in Louisiana found Khalil deportable based on Secretary Rubio’s assertion that his presence carries “adverse foreign policy consequences.”
– Attorneys say the judge reached that finding without reviewing the evidence behind the Secretary’s assertion.
– Khalil’s legal team sought asylum and argued his detention lacked a valid warrant.
– The government is seeking to deport him to Algeria or Syria.
– His attorneys submitted more than 600 pages of records and expert assessments to show he is not antisemitic and that removal could expose him to torture or death.

At home, life changed quickly: Khalil’s wife, Dr. Noor Abdalla, gave birth to their son in April 2025. Advocates worked with the detention center to allow the family to meet without a plexiglass barrier.

Broad Support and Unusual Framing

Support for both men spans communities that do not always agree on Middle East politics. Some Israeli academics and peace activists issued letters urging fair treatment and condemning punishment of campus speech. Their involvement underscores the unusual nature of the government’s approach: targeting green card holders at or soon after immigration appointments and framing the cases around a foreign policy claim rather than allegations of specific acts of violence or material support to a banned group.

Obscure Foreign Policy Provision at Center of Cases

At the heart of both matters is a little-known power that allows the Secretary of State to label a noncitizen a danger to U.S. foreign policy interests. That label can sidestep typical protections for lawful permanent residents in removal cases.

Legal concerns raised by counsel:
– The power lacks clear standards and meaningful review, raising due process alarms.
– Attorneys say the provision lets the executive branch reach into routine immigration steps—like a citizenship interview—and convert them into arrest points for people whose views the government dislikes.
– Immigration judges must decide how much weight to give a top diplomat’s statement when underlying evidence is not entered into the record.
– In Khalil’s case, attorneys say the judge credited the Secretary’s assertion without examining proof—a practice they anticipate challenging on appeal.

ICE and the Department of Homeland Security are enforcing these actions, while the Department of State’s role—specifically Secretary Rubio’s determinations—has become the focal point.

Context and Chilling Effects

These decisions come against a tense national backdrop: ongoing conflict in Gaza, campus protests, and rising disputes over speech that spill into employment and immigration.

Consequences and concerns:
– For Palestinians with green cards, the risk calculus has shifted; detentions at or right after immigration appointments create a chilling effect.
– Families, employers, and universities now face uncertainty as long-settled residents confront sudden removal threats tied to political expression rather than conduct.
– Analysis by VisaVerge.com highlights that these detentions undermine the predictability of routine immigration steps and heighten fear among those engaged in advocacy.

For context, a USCIS naturalization interview is usually administrative, covering eligibility, English and civics, and updates to background checks. The public can review how USCIS describes the interview and test at the agency’s official page: USCIS Naturalization Interview and Test. In these cases, however, the interview setting became a point of arrest, adding fear that what should be a step toward citizenship can turn into detention for those engaged in public advocacy.

Human Impact

The human cost is stark and immediate:
– Mahdawi: a decade-long tie to the U.S., campus leader, now separated from community and studies.
– Khalil: a newborn son (born April 2025) and a U.S. citizen spouse dealing with family separation and emotional strain.
– Spouses, parents, and classmates face sudden separation, mounting legal fees, and travel limits to visit detention centers that are often far from home.

Advocates and counsel emphasize family and medical concerns, including bonding needs for newborns and access to in-person visits without physical barriers.

Legal Strategies and Possible Outcomes

Legal teams for both men have pursued parallel strategies:
1. Challenge the detention process in federal court (habeas corpus).
2. Fight removal in immigration court.
3. Highlight the lack of transparency in the foreign policy claim.

They argue:
– The government is punishing speech, not conduct.
– Deporting Palestinian activists could expose them to grave harm abroad.
– Use of this foreign policy tool is rare and controversial, lacking the checks seen in other parts of immigration law.

Potential institutional responses:
– Some members of Congress have shown interest, with advocates contacting Senator Mark Welch’s office for updates.
– While no formal legislation is reported, continued detentions could spur oversight requests or hearings.
– Courts may eventually set boundaries on the Secretary of State’s authority if higher appeals take up the foreign policy designation question.

Practical Advice and Precautions

For immigrants concerned about speaking out, lawyers recommend:
– Document peaceful activity and public advocacy thoroughly.
– Keep records of community ties (employment, family, educational history).
– Stay in close contact with counsel if contacted by ICE.
– Plan for emergencies: childcare, medical needs, and contingency finances if a breadwinner is detained.

Universities are reviewing support systems for international and immigrant students who face legal risks tied to political activity on campus.

Why These Cases Matter

These cases will likely influence how agencies handle activists at immigration appointments and whether foreign policy claims can override usual protections for green card holders.

Until judges weigh in further, the fear of being detained during a routine step remains real for many Palestinian residents and their allies.

For now, Mahdawi and Khalil remain in legal limbo, their futures tied to court calendars and a diplomatic power few had heard of before this spring.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1
Why was Mohsen Mahdawi detained during his USCIS naturalization interview?
Authorities detained Mahdawi on April 14, 2025, and placed him in deportation proceedings using a rare Secretary of State foreign-policy designation the government says justifies removal. His lawyers contend the detention targeted his Palestinian identity and activism and that proper due process was not followed.

Q2
What is the Secretary of State foreign-policy authority used in these cases?
The authority allows the Secretary of State to label a noncitizen as harmful to U.S. foreign policy interests, which can be used to support removal even for lawful permanent residents. Critics say the power lacks clear standards and meaningful judicial review when underlying evidence is not entered into the immigration record.

Q3
How are Mahdawi and Khalil’s legal teams responding?
Both teams filed habeas corpus petitions and are contesting removal in immigration court, arguing violations of statutory and due process rights, lack of transparency in the foreign-policy claim, and that the government is effectively punishing protected political speech.

Q4
What practical steps should green card holders take if concerned about immigration-related risks tied to activism?
Lawyers recommend documenting peaceful advocacy, keeping records of employment and family ties, maintaining close contact with counsel if contacted by ICE, and preparing emergency plans for childcare and finances. Seeking early legal assistance and university support services can also help manage risks.

VisaVerge.com
Learn Today
ICE → U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the federal agency that enforces immigration laws and detains noncitizens.
USCIS → U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, the agency that processes naturalization and immigration benefits.
Naturalization interview → A USCIS appointment to evaluate an applicant’s eligibility for U.S. citizenship, including English and civics testing.
Foreign policy designation → A rarely used authority allowing the Secretary of State to declare a noncitizen a threat to U.S. foreign policy interests.
Habeas corpus → A federal legal petition challenging unlawful detention and seeking release or review of custody conditions.
Lawful permanent resident → A noncitizen who holds a green card and has the right to live and work permanently in the United States.
Deportation/removal proceedings → Legal processes through which the government seeks to expel a noncitizen from the United States.

This Article in a Nutshell

Mohsen K. Mahdawi, a Palestinian student and Columbia organizer, was detained by ICE during a USCIS naturalization interview on April 14, 2025, and placed in deportation proceedings. The administration relies on an obscure foreign-policy authority attributed to Secretary of State Marco Rubio to justify removal, prompting habeas corpus petitions alleging due process violations and punishment for protected speech. A parallel case, Mahmoud Khalil, was arrested in March 2025; a Louisiana judge found him deportable in May 2025 based on the Secretary’s assertion despite defense claims and extensive documentation. Lawyers warn the authority lacks clear standards and meaningful review, creating chilling effects for Palestinian green card holders and campus activists. Advocates call for legal support, congressional oversight, and judicial limits on the Secretary’s power as courts weigh these cases.

— VisaVerge.com
Share This Article
Facebook Pinterest Whatsapp Whatsapp Reddit Email Copy Link Print
What do you think?
Happy0
Sad0
Angry0
Embarrass0
Surprise0
Visa Verge
ByVisa Verge
Senior Editor
Follow:
VisaVerge.com is a premier online destination dedicated to providing the latest and most comprehensive news on immigration, visas, and global travel. Our platform is designed for individuals navigating the complexities of international travel and immigration processes. With a team of experienced journalists and industry experts, we deliver in-depth reporting, breaking news, and informative guides. Whether it's updates on visa policies, insights into travel trends, or tips for successful immigration, VisaVerge.com is committed to offering reliable, timely, and accurate information to our global audience. Our mission is to empower readers with knowledge, making international travel and relocation smoother and more accessible.
Subscribe
Login
Notify of
guest

guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
U.S. Visa Invitation Letter Guide with Sample Letters
Visa

U.S. Visa Invitation Letter Guide with Sample Letters

U.S. Re-entry Requirements After International Travel
Knowledge

U.S. Re-entry Requirements After International Travel

Opening a Bank Account in the UK for US Citizens: A Guide for Expats
Knowledge

Opening a Bank Account in the UK for US Citizens: A Guide for Expats

Guide to Filling Out the Customs Declaration Form 6059B in the US
Travel

Guide to Filling Out the Customs Declaration Form 6059B in the US

How to Get a B-2 Tourist Visa for Your Parents
Guides

How to Get a B-2 Tourist Visa for Your Parents

How to Fill Form I-589: Asylum Application Guide
Guides

How to Fill Form I-589: Asylum Application Guide

Visa Requirements and Documents for Traveling to Cote d’Ivoire (Ivory Coast)
Knowledge

Visa Requirements and Documents for Traveling to Cote d’Ivoire (Ivory Coast)

Renew Indian Passport in USA: Step-by-Step Guide
Knowledge

Renew Indian Passport in USA: Step-by-Step Guide

You Might Also Like

Denver Judge Issues Nuanced Injunction on Immigration Subpoena for Immigrant Children
Immigration

Denver Judge Issues Nuanced Injunction on Immigration Subpoena for Immigrant Children

By Visa Verge
Even With Massive Funding, ICE Struggles to Hire New Agents
Immigration

Even With Massive Funding, ICE Struggles to Hire New Agents

By Oliver Mercer
Unexpected ICE Raid at Arkansas Park Sparks Local Outcry and Questions
Immigration

Unexpected ICE Raid at Arkansas Park Sparks Local Outcry and Questions

By Shashank Singh
John Oliver Calls ICE Crackdown ‘Driving Up Arrests at All Costs’
Immigration

John Oliver Calls ICE Crackdown ‘Driving Up Arrests at All Costs’

By Jim Grey
Show More
VisaVerge official logo in Light white color VisaVerge official logo in Light white color
Facebook Twitter Youtube Rss Instagram Android

About US


At VisaVerge, we understand that the journey of immigration and travel is more than just a process; it’s a deeply personal experience that shapes futures and fulfills dreams. Our mission is to demystify the intricacies of immigration laws, visa procedures, and travel information, making them accessible and understandable for everyone.

Trending
  • Canada
  • F1Visa
  • Guides
  • Legal
  • NRI
  • Questions
  • Situations
  • USCIS
Useful Links
  • History
  • Holidays 2025
  • LinkInBio
  • My Feed
  • My Saves
  • My Interests
  • Resources Hub
  • Contact USCIS
VisaVerge

2025 © VisaVerge. All Rights Reserved.

  • About US
  • Community Guidelines
  • Contact US
  • Cookie Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Ethics Statement
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
wpDiscuz
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?