Key Takeaways
• A Donegal man detained by ICE faces deportation after overstaying his visa waiver in Boston for 15 years.
• Trump’s 2025 Executive Order 14159 enforces strict immigration rules with daily ICE detention quotas of 1,800 noncitizens.
• Irish green card holders and visa waiver overstays face deportation despite family ties or minor convictions.
An Irish Man from Donegal Faces Deportation After Years in the U.S.: What the New Immigration Crackdown Means for Irish Nationals
A Donegal native who has lived in Boston for over 15 years is now facing imminent deportation from the United States 🇺🇸, highlighting the harsh reality of America’s new immigration enforcement policies. Detained by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in May 2025, this man’s case has become a focal point for Irish communities and immigration advocates on both sides of the Atlantic. His story is not unique—he is one of several Irish nationals recently swept up in a wave of detentions and deportations, many triggered by minor or decades-old convictions.
This article explains what happened, why it matters, and what Irish nationals and their families need to know about the current U.S. immigration landscape.
Who Is Affected and Why Now?
The Donegal man, whose name has not been released, built a life in Boston, working, raising two U.S.-born children, and running a business in New England. His trouble began after a driving-related conviction, which led ICE to detain him for violating the terms of his visa waiver. Despite legal appeals and requests for alternatives like electronic monitoring, ICE has refused to release him, and his attorney estimates his chance of release at just 1%.
He is not alone. Since April 2025, several Irish nationals—including some with green cards—have faced detention or deportation, often for minor offenses or old convictions. According to analysis by VisaVerge.com, these cases have drawn sharp attention from Irish media, advocacy groups, and the Irish government.
What Changed in U.S. Immigration Policy?
Executive Orders and Enforcement
The shift began in January 2025, when President Donald Trump returned to office and signed Executive Order 14159, “Protecting the American People Against Invasion.” This order directs the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to strictly enforce all immigration laws, prioritize the removal of inadmissible and removable noncitizens, and revoke previous Biden-era enforcement priorities.
Key changes include:
- Zero Discretion Policy: ICE field offices must detain a minimum number of noncitizens daily, with almost no room for individual circumstances—even for long-term residents or parents of U.S. citizen children.
- Mandatory Registration: All noncitizens must register and be fingerprinted under INA Section 262. Failure to comply is now both a civil and criminal enforcement priority.
- Paused Green Card Processing: As of March 25, 2025, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) has paused green card processing for certain categories, including refugees and asylees, pending additional security vetting. While this does not directly affect employment- or family-based green card applicants, it signals a broader tightening of legal immigration pathways.
Official government information on green cards and enforcement can be found at USCIS.gov.
How Does This Affect Irish Nationals?
Visa Waiver Overstays
Many Irish nationals in the U.S. entered on the Visa Waiver Program (VWP), which allows citizens of Ireland 🇮🇪 and other countries to visit the U.S. for up to 90 days without a visa for tourism or business. However, the VWP strictly prohibits extensions or changes of status. Overstaying the VWP means:
- Ineligibility for Most Relief: Individuals who overstay cannot usually adjust their status or apply for most forms of relief.
- Immediate Removal: ICE can detain and deport visa waiver overstays without a hearing.
The Donegal man reportedly overstayed his visa waiver, making him especially vulnerable under the new enforcement regime.
Green Card Holders Also at Risk
Even Irish nationals with green cards (permanent resident status) have faced detention or deportation proceedings, especially if they have any criminal record—even for minor or decades-old offenses. Under previous administrations, ICE often exercised discretion in such cases, considering factors like length of U.S. residence, family ties, and rehabilitation. That is no longer the case.
The Numbers: Detention and Deportation on the Rise
- ICE Detention Quotas: ICE is now required to detain at least 1,800 noncitizens per day nationwide, up from a daily average of 415 in 2023.
- Undocumented Irish: There are an estimated 10,000–15,000 undocumented Irish nationals in the U.S., many of whom have lived in the country for decades and have U.S.-born children.
- Green Card Backlogs: Family-based green card wait times remain unchanged, while some employment-based categories have seen modest movement. The EB-4 category is currently unavailable until the new fiscal year.
What Happens During Deportation Proceedings?
Step-by-Step Process
- Detention: ICE detains individuals found in violation of immigration status or with criminal convictions.
- Legal Representation: Detainees may seek legal counsel and request alternatives to detention, such as ankle bracelets or electronic monitoring. Under current policy, these requests are almost always denied.
- Removal Proceedings: Cases are processed quickly, with limited opportunity for discretionary relief.
- Consular Assistance: The Irish government, through its Department of Foreign Affairs, may provide consular support but cannot intervene in U.S. legal proceedings.
- Appeals: Legal appeals are possible but face steep odds under current enforcement priorities.
For official information on ICE detention and removal, visit ICE.gov.
Real-Life Impact: The Donegal Man’s Story
The Donegal man’s case is a stark example of how current policies affect real people:
- Long-Term Resident: He lived in Boston for over 15 years, built a business, and raised two U.S.-born children.
- Minor Conviction: His detention was triggered by a driving-related conviction, not a violent crime.
- No Discretion: Despite his deep community ties and family responsibilities, ICE refused to consider alternatives to detention or removal.
- Legal Limbo: He waited three years for a green card, but his overstay and conviction left him with almost no legal options.
His attorney, John Foley, says his chance of release is just 1%. This is the new reality for many Irish nationals and other immigrants under the current enforcement regime.
What Are the Irish and U.S. Governments Doing?
Irish Government Response
Ireland’s Department of Foreign Affairs is providing consular assistance to affected citizens but does not comment on individual cases. Irish Taoiseach Micheál Martin has stated, “where people have green cards and citizenship rights there shouldn’t be an issue,” and that the government is pursuing these cases bilaterally with the U.S.
U.S. Lawmakers and Advocacy
Some U.S. lawmakers, such as Congressman Jimmy Panetta, have criticized the detention of long-term residents and green card holders for old or expunged convictions, calling such actions “unfathomable and unacceptable.” Civil rights organizations warn that the new policies risk widespread civil liberties violations and family separations.
Policy Implications: No Room for Discretion
Who Is Most at Risk?
- Undocumented Irish nationals who entered on the visa waiver and overstayed.
- Green card holders with any criminal record, even if the offense is minor or decades old.
- Long-term residents with deep community ties, businesses, and U.S. citizen children.
What Has Changed?
- No Discretion: ICE officers have almost no authority to consider individual circumstances.
- Mandatory Registration: All noncitizens must register and be fingerprinted, or face enforcement action.
- Legal Limbo: Green card processing delays and pauses have left many in uncertainty.
What Should Affected Individuals Do?
Immediate Steps
- Consult an Experienced Immigration Attorney: Legal advice is critical. The American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) and local Irish immigration centers can help.
- Contact the Irish Consulate: The Irish Department of Foreign Affairs offers consular assistance and can provide guidance.
- Gather Documentation: Collect all immigration paperwork, proof of U.S. residence, family ties, and any evidence of rehabilitation or community involvement.
- Stay Informed: Monitor official government updates and policy changes.
Useful Resources
- U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)
- U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
- Irish Department of Foreign Affairs
- AILA Immigration Lawyer Search
Broader Context: Why Is This Happening?
Historical Background
- Visa Waiver Program (VWP): Allows Irish citizens to visit the U.S. for up to 90 days without a visa, but overstaying leads to ineligibility for most relief and makes individuals subject to immediate removal.
- Previous Discretion: Under prior administrations, ICE often considered humanitarian factors in removal cases. Now, such discretion is almost entirely gone.
- Green Card Backlogs: Even eligible applicants face years-long waits, and recent policy changes have further slowed or paused processing for some categories.
Recent Policy Changes
- Executive Order 14159: Mandates strict enforcement and removal priorities.
- Detention Quotas: ICE must detain at least 1,800 noncitizens per day.
- Program Terminations: Some humanitarian parole programs have ended, affecting hundreds of thousands, though not directly impacting Irish nationals.
Looking Ahead: What’s Next for Irish Nationals in the U.S.?
Continued Strict Enforcement
The Trump administration has signaled no intention to relax enforcement or restore discretion in removal cases. Legal challenges to some executive orders are underway, with Supreme Court decisions expected by June 2025, but practical relief for those facing deportation remains unlikely in the short term.
Irish Government Advocacy
Ireland 🇮🇪 is expected to continue bilateral discussions with the U.S. to seek relief for affected citizens, but outcomes are uncertain. Community leaders urge both governments to find a path to regularization or relief for long-term undocumented Irish residents.
Summary Table: Key Facts
| Issue | Detail |
|---|---|
| Latest Case | Donegal man detained by ICE, facing deportation after 15 years in Boston |
| Policy Change | Strict enforcement, no discretion, mandatory registration, increased daily detentions |
| Green Card Wait | Processing delays, some categories paused, backlogs persist |
| Irish Govt. Response | Providing consular assistance, pursuing cases bilaterally |
| Legal Relief | Severely limited, especially for visa waiver overstays and those with convictions |
| Future Outlook | Continued strict enforcement, pending court challenges, ongoing advocacy |
Practical Takeaways
- If you or a loved one is undocumented or facing deportation, seek legal advice immediately.
- Stay in contact with the Irish consulate for support and guidance.
- Keep all immigration documents and proof of U.S. ties organized and accessible.
- Monitor official updates from USCIS and ICE for changes in policy or procedure.
For more detailed analysis and updates on U.S. immigration policy, VisaVerge.com reports that the current environment leaves little room for relief, especially for those with visa waiver overstays or criminal convictions.
The Donegal man’s case is a warning for thousands of Irish nationals in the U.S.: under current policies, even long-term residents with deep roots and families are at risk of deportation. Immediate action, legal support, and staying informed are more important than ever.
Learn Today
Visa Waiver Program (VWP) → Allows citizens of certain countries, including Ireland, to visit the U.S. for up to 90 days without a visa.
ICE → U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency responsible for enforcing immigration laws and detaining noncitizens.
Green Card → Also called permanent resident card, grants lawful permanent residence in the United States.
Executive Order 14159 → 2025 presidential order enforcing strict immigration laws and prioritizing removal of noncitizens.
Detention Quotas → Mandatory numbers of noncitizens ICE must detain daily under new immigration enforcement policies.
This Article in a Nutshell
A Donegal man faces deportation after 15 years in Boston due to visa overstay and minor conviction. Trump’s 2025 immigration crackdown mandates strict detention quotas, eliminating discretion even for long-term Irish residents and green card holders. Legal options are limited, highlighting new risks for Irish nationals in the U.S.
— By VisaVerge.com
Read more:
• Deportation debate grows as European Commission defends language choice
• KXAN report reveals new trends in deportation across Texas
• Trump Administration Unleashes Deportation Blitz Nationwide
• Trump Administration Slammed for Secret Deportation Move
• Appeals court orders return of Daniel Lozano-Camargo after deportation
