Disabled Man Trapped in ICE Custody Under Trump Orders

Key Takeaways

• Bay, a deaf and mute asylum-seeker, spent over 80 days detained at Otay Mesa without interpreters or legal help.
• Trump-era immigration policies cut legal aid like NQRP and increased expedited removal and privatized detention, worsening conditions for disabled detainees.
• Private centers lack oversight, leaving disabled migrants isolated, often without interpreters, medical care, or protection during accelerated deportation processes.

A recent case at the Otay Mesa Detention Center has exposed the troubling impact of policies that began under President Trump, especially on people with disabilities held in ICE custody. The story of a deaf and mute man known as “Bay” has drawn attention to deep problems within the system. Many worry these issues are worse for those least able to speak up for themselves. The growing reliance on strict immigration enforcement, rapid deportation, private detention centers, and the cutting of legal and interpretation services have changed the landscape for disabled detainees. This article takes a close look at Bay’s situation and explains how Trump immigration orders have shaped outcomes for others in similar positions.

Bay’s Ordeal: Alone in Detention, Without a Voice

Bay, a man from Mongolia, has been trapped inside Otay Mesa Detention Center for more than 80 days. He is both deaf and mute, making communication very difficult. When Bay arrived at the border, he gave officials a written letter in Mongolian that explained why he was seeking asylum in the United States 🇺🇸. However, reports say immigration staff would not even look at his written plea. With no interpreter who knows Mongolian Sign Language, Bay could not explain himself or follow what was going on.

According to his sister, Bay’s world in ICE custody is one of total silence. He does not know what will happen to him or how to take part in legal proceedings about his future. With no access to a judge, and no lawyer or interpreter, he has no way to communicate. Bay’s sister wanted him to stay with her while his asylum case moved forward. Now, though, she fears for his safety and his mental health. She knows that before coming to the United States 🇺🇸, Bay suffered abuse in Mongolia because of his disability. Being completely alone and unable to speak or understand what’s happening adds more trauma on top of that.

The Impact of Trump Immigration Orders

Bay’s case is not unusual under the rules shaped by President Trump’s policies. In the years after 2017, the United States 🇺🇸 made sweeping changes to how it deals with immigrants at the border and inside the country. These Trump immigration orders and executive actions changed a few key areas:

1. Expansion of Expedited Removal

   Under President Trump, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) gained more power to deport people quickly. Expedited removal is a fast-track process. Now, many can be deported without ever seeing an immigration judge, unless they can prove they’ve lived in the United States 🇺🇸 for at least two years. For new arrivals, or people who, like Bay, cannot communicate easily, meeting such a demand is almost impossible.

2. Cuts to Legal Aid and Specialized Support Programs

   Several programs offered help to immigrants who struggled to represent themselves because of mental illness or cognitive disabilities. One important support was the National Qualified Representative Program (NQRP). It helped provide lawyers or other helpers for people in ICE custody who could not understand their deportation cases. However, during the Trump administration, this and other legal aid programs were either defunded or canceled—even after courts challenged the cuts. With these services gone, thousands of detainees now have little or no chance of understanding or fighting their case.

3. Erosion of Due Process

   In the U.S. legal system, “due process” means every person should get a fair chance to present their story before the government can take away their freedom. The new immigration rules made it easier for judges to skip live hearings. Instead, judges could now reject asylum claims based only on written documents. This step is especially harsh for people who cannot write or communicate well, such as those with language barriers or cognitive disabilities. Without help, a person like Bay cannot explain in writing why they are afraid to return to their home country.

4. Rise of Private Detention Centers

   Another major shift was the increased use of privately operated detention centers. Otay Mesa Detention Center, where Bay is held, is run by a company called CoreCivic. Private facilities have been criticized for putting profit over the needs of detainees. Oversight is less strict, and specialized services—like sign language interpreters or mental health support—may not be a priority. Reports say that private facilities are more likely to be overcrowded, placing greater stress on people already in fragile condition.

Consequences for Disabled Immigrants

These new policies hit people with disabilities the hardest. They face several challenges:

• No Interpreters: Immigrants who are deaf, blind, or have intellectual disabilities often do not get the interpreters who can help them explain their story or follow legal proceedings. ICE staff may not be trained or may lack the tools to communicate in languages like Mongolian Sign Language.

• No Legal Representation: With cuts to the NQRP and other programs, people who cannot understand what is happening to them have no legal help. They can even be ordered deported without knowing what the word “deportation” means.

• Isolation and Mental Health Risks: Forced to spend long periods alone, separated from family, and unable to speak with others, mentally fragile detainees easily become depressed or anxious. Detention centers can be loud, unpredictable, and frightening, especially for those with special needs.

• Physical Health Problems: Without oversight, some private centers cannot or do not provide the medical care or medicines that people with physical disabilities need. This can make existing health problems worse.

What the Law Says—and What Happens in Practice

Federal law says that all public programs in the United States 🇺🇸, including immigration courts and ICE, must not discriminate against people with disabilities. The Rehabilitation Act and Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) both contain rules against unfair treatment by government agencies. In theory, this means ICE must offer interpreters and make reasonable efforts to provide equal access to legal proceedings.

But experts say that, in practice, these protections often do not reach people like Bay. Without legal pressure or clear policies in each detention center, disabled detainees can slip through the cracks. Immigration lawyers and advocacy groups argue that cuts to legal and interpretation services are against the law. However, with current rules and court enforcement lagging, many fear that vulnerable people will continue to be neglected or even wrongfully deported.

Expert Voices: Calling for Change

Liz Hoefer, a representative from the Galveston-Houston Immigrant Representation Project, spoke out against recent policy changes. She warned: “For most individuals who are mentally incompetent… presenting a claim… is insurmountable. Without NQRP… they will be deported without even understanding the proceedings…”

Advocates are urging lawmakers and the Department of Homeland Security to restore legal aid and special programs for detainees with disabilities. They also ask for increased oversight of private detention centers, especially ones run by companies like CoreCivic.

Otay Mesa Detention Center: A Case Study

The story of Otay Mesa Detention Center provides a closer look at the challenges discussed above. The facility houses hundreds of people at a time. Since it is run by a private company, many watch-dog groups worry about the lack of accountability and the limited focus on care for special-needs detainees.

For example, because Mongolian Sign Language interpreters are rare, someone like Bay has almost no hope of meaningful communication. Otay Mesa’s staff may be well-meaning but are rarely prepared for such unique needs. Even when staff want to help, they often have no tools or guidance for how to do so.

Private management also tends to create pressure to lower costs, which can mean fewer staff, fewer services, and less access to medical or psychological help. For someone facing trauma or past abuse, this environment can be truly dangerous.

Table: How Trump Policy Changes Impacted Disabled Detainees

Wider Effects: The Human Toll

The rules put in place during the Trump years undercut many of the safety measures once designed to protect immigrants with special needs. The story of Bay is just one among many. People with serious medical, cognitive, or communication challenges are especially unsafe in detention when programs that would help them are gone.

Those who cannot communicate cannot protect themselves. Unable to understand orders, without anyone to speak for them, they become invisible within a crowded and sometimes overwhelmed system. Family members often have no information or ability to intervene. For the broader community, this means lost trust in immigration procedures and more fear among people seeking help or protection at the border.

For more information on official detention policies and the rights of detainees, readers can visit the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Detention Management page.

Potential Paths Forward

Many immigration experts and human rights groups call for important changes:

• Restoring programs like the NQRP, which offer legal counsel to people who cannot defend themselves in court
• Stronger requirements for interpreters fluent in less common sign languages and spoken languages
• More oversight of private detention centers, with public reporting on how people with disabilities are treated
• A return to “parole” for asylum-seekers who have family in the country, instead of automatic detention

As reported by VisaVerge.com, the increased focus on detention and cost-cutting has made life much harder for the most vulnerable migrants. Without legal help, many are left to face complex rules they cannot understand, often in isolation and poor conditions.

Conclusion: Justice or Deterrence?

Bay’s experience at the Otay Mesa Detention Center is not just a personal tragedy. It is a warning sign about a system that puts enforcement and speed ahead of fairness, especially under Trump immigration orders. These policies did not give enough thought to the needs of people with disabilities. Without a return to legal support, interpreter access, and careful oversight, others like Bay will remain at risk of being lost in a system they cannot understand.

Lawyers, family, and advocates hope the public and the government will step in to restore fairness. For detainees with disabilities, justice depends on real access to communication, lawyers, and medical care—not just being warehoused until a decision is made. Policymakers face a choice: build a system that keeps people out, or one that values everyone’s right to be heard and protected, no matter their abilities.

Learn Today

Expedited Removal → A fast-track deportation process letting officials remove immigrants without a hearing before a judge unless certain criteria are met.
NQRP (National Qualified Representative Program) → A federal program providing legal representation to immigrants in detention with mental disabilities, since defunded during Trump’s administration.
Otay Mesa Detention Center → A privately operated immigration detention facility in California, managed by CoreCivic, known for housing ICE detainees.
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) → A U.S. law requiring public agencies to provide equal access and anti-discrimination protections for people with disabilities.
CoreCivic → A private company that manages correctional and detention facilities, including immigration centers like Otay Mesa, often criticized for reduced oversight.

This Article in a Nutshell

A Mongolian asylum-seeker, Bay, is trapped in ICE’s Otay Mesa Detention Center—deaf, mute, and without interpreters. Trump-era policy changes, including cuts to legal aid like NQRP and increased privatized detention, particularly harm disabled migrants. Lacking access to justice and care, they risk silent deportation in privatized, profit-driven facilities.
— By VisaVerge.com

Read more:

• Boeing Orders Skyrocket After Trump Trade Deals
• Denver Sues Trump Administration Over FEMA Migrant Funds
• Homan Slams AOC in Fierce Trump Administration Showdown
• Donald Trump Unleashes New Tariff Rates on His Own
• Trump Shuts Down Asylum System on Day One