Praful Patel Criticizes Singapore Airlines for Silence After Air India Crash

The June 2025 Air India Flight AI171 crash killed 241 passengers and 29 on the ground. Singapore Airlines’ 25.1% stake drew criticism for delayed crisis communication. DGCA initiated investigations and enhanced Boeing 787 safety protocols, highlighting a need for stricter foreign stakeholder oversight in Indian aviation.

Key Takeaways

• Air India Flight AI171 crashed near Ahmedabad on June 12, 2025, killing 241 passengers and 29 on the ground.
• Singapore Airlines owns 25.1% of Air India but delayed public response, drawing criticism from Praful Patel.
• DGCA ordered enhanced Boeing 787 surveillance and safety protocols; 66 flights canceled after the crash.

On June 12, 2025, tragedy struck when Air India Flight AI171, a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, crashed shortly after taking off from Ahmedabad on its way to London. The crash claimed the lives of 241 out of 242 people on board, leaving only one survivor, and caused at least 29 deaths on the ground. This event stands as one of the deadliest aviation disasters in India in recent decades. The aftermath has sparked intense debate about corporate responsibility, crisis communication, and the role of foreign stakeholders in Indian aviation, especially focusing on Singapore Airlines and its involvement with Air India.

What Happened: The Crash and Immediate Response

Praful Patel Criticizes Singapore Airlines for Silence After Air India Crash
Praful Patel Criticizes Singapore Airlines for Silence After Air India Crash

Air India Flight AI171 took off from Ahmedabad with 242 people on board. Within minutes, the aircraft encountered a catastrophic failure. According to initial findings, the plane’s emergency power system, known as the ram air turbine, was activated before the crash. This system only deploys when both engines fail or there is a major electrical problem, suggesting a severe technical issue occurred in flight.

The crash resulted in a devastating loss of life, with only one person surviving from those on board. Additionally, debris and fire from the crash led to at least 29 fatalities among people on the ground. Emergency services responded quickly, but the scale of the disaster was overwhelming.

Stakeholder Reactions: Praful Patel’s Criticism and Singapore Airlines’ Silence

In the days following the crash, public attention turned not only to the technical causes but also to how the involved companies responded. Former Civil Aviation Minister Praful Patel, a senior leader of the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), openly criticized Singapore Airlines for its delayed public response. Patel pointed out that Singapore Airlines holds a 25.1% stake in Air India and plays a major role in its management and maintenance. He described the airline’s silence as “deafening” and “surprising,” especially given its deep operational involvement.

Patel’s criticism raised important questions about the responsibilities of foreign stakeholders in Indian airlines. He emphasized that Air India’s CEO, Campbell Wilson, is a nominee of Singapore Airlines and previously led Scoot, SIA’s low-cost subsidiary. This means Singapore Airlines is not just a passive investor but is actively involved in Air India’s daily operations and decision-making.

Singapore Airlines’ Response and Ongoing Support

Nearly a week after the crash, Singapore Airlines finally issued a public statement. The airline expressed condolences to the families of the victims and affirmed its ongoing support to Tata Sons and Air India. Singapore Airlines stated it had been in “close contact” with its partners and was offering “full support and all necessary assistance” during the crisis.

The delayed response drew criticism from many quarters, but Singapore Airlines highlighted its operational partnership and board representation in Air India. CEO Goh Choon Phong, who sits on Air India’s board, and other SIA executives are closely involved in Air India’s turnaround plans, especially after the Vistara-Air India merger in November 2024.

Investigations and Regulatory Actions

Ongoing Investigations

The Indian government responded quickly by launching multiple investigations:

  • Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA): India’s main aviation regulator began a technical and operational analysis of the crash.
  • Air India’s Internal Safety Board: Conducted its own review of maintenance and operational records.
  • High-Level Government Committee: Led by the Union Home Secretary, this committee was tasked with a thorough probe, with a report expected within three months.

Early findings suggest that the activation of the ram air turbine points to a possible dual engine failure or a major electrical problem. However, experts stress that a full investigation is needed before drawing any final conclusions.

Regulatory Oversight and Safety Measures

In response to the crash, the DGCA ordered enhanced surveillance of Air India’s entire Boeing 787 fleet, which includes 26 787-8s and 7 787-9s. The regulator did not find any major safety concerns but issued several directives to improve safety and coordination:

  • Strengthen internal coordination between maintenance and operations teams.
  • Ensure availability of spare parts for the Boeing 787 fleet.
  • Improve real-time defect reporting to catch problems before they become serious.
  • Enhance passenger communication during delays or cancellations.

Between June 12 and June 17, 66 scheduled B787 flights were canceled, while 248 flights operated as planned. These cancellations, along with unrelated airspace closures over Iran, caused significant disruptions for passengers.

For more information on aviation safety regulations and ongoing investigations, readers can visit the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) official website.

Corporate Accountability and Public Debate

The Role of Foreign Stakeholders

The crash has sparked a wider debate about the responsibilities of foreign companies that hold significant stakes in Indian airlines. Singapore Airlines’ 25.1% ownership of Air India, along with its board representation and operational involvement, means it has a direct role in how the airline is managed and maintained.

Praful Patel’s criticism focused on the need for transparent and timely crisis communication from all major stakeholders, not just the majority owner. He questioned why Singapore Airlines, with its deep involvement in Air India’s operations, did not issue a public statement sooner.

Crisis Communication and Public Expectations

The delayed response from Singapore Airlines highlighted the importance of clear and prompt communication in the aftermath of such tragedies. Aviation experts and corporate governance analysts agree that all major stakeholders, especially those with operational control, must be transparent and proactive during crises.

Analysis from VisaVerge.com suggests that the incident may lead to new rules requiring foreign stakeholders in Indian airlines to take a more active role in crisis management and public communication. This could include mandatory public statements, regular updates to families of victims, and closer cooperation with Indian authorities.

Impact on Passengers and Airline Operations

Flight Cancellations and Disruptions

The crash and the subsequent regulatory actions led to widespread disruptions for Air India passengers. The DGCA’s enhanced surveillance and safety checks resulted in the cancellation of 66 Boeing 787 flights in just five days. Passengers faced delays, rerouting, and uncertainty as airlines worked to adjust schedules and ensure safety.

Airlines were instructed to communicate clearly with passengers about delays and cancellations and to provide alternate routing when possible. Regulators emphasized the need for timely updates and support for affected travelers.

Passenger Safety and Service Standards

The incident has put a spotlight on the importance of robust maintenance systems, real-time defect reporting, and cross-departmental coordination. The DGCA’s directives aim to ensure that airlines not only meet safety standards but also provide high-quality service to passengers, especially during emergencies.

Background: Air India’s Privatization and Singapore Airlines’ Involvement

Air India’s Recent History

Air India was privatized in 2022, with Tata Sons becoming the majority owner. As part of a strategic partnership, Singapore Airlines acquired a 25.1% stake in Air India. This partnership deepened after the merger of Vistara (a joint venture between Tata Sons and SIA) with Air India in November 2024.

Codeshare Agreements and Maintenance

Singapore Airlines and Air India have extensive codeshare agreements, allowing them to share flights and coordinate schedules. SIA is also responsible for maintaining a large portion of Air India’s wide-body fleet, including the Boeing 787s.

Leadership Integration

Air India’s current CEO, Campbell Wilson, is a nominee of Singapore Airlines and previously led Scoot, SIA’s low-cost subsidiary. This leadership integration means that SIA’s influence extends beyond board meetings to the daily management and strategic direction of Air India.

Policy Implications and Future Reforms

Anticipated Investigation Results

The high-level government committee’s findings, due within three months, are expected to clarify the technical causes of the crash and assign accountability. The results may also lead to policy changes aimed at preventing similar incidents in the future.

Possible Policy Reforms

Based on expert analysis and public debate, several reforms are likely to be considered:

  • Stricter oversight of foreign stakeholders in Indian airlines, especially regarding crisis communication and operational control.
  • Enhanced maintenance protocols to ensure that all aircraft meet the highest safety standards.
  • Improved crisis communication standards, requiring all major stakeholders to issue timely public statements and updates.

Operational Changes for Air India and Singapore Airlines

Both Air India and Singapore Airlines may face pressure to increase transparency and public engagement after major incidents. This could include more frequent updates to passengers, closer cooperation with regulators, and greater accountability for maintenance and safety.

Multiple Perspectives: How Different Groups Are Responding

Stakeholder Perspective/Response
Praful Patel (NCP) Criticized SIA’s delayed response, questioned accountability of major foreign stakeholders
Singapore Airlines Issued condolences after criticism, affirmed ongoing support, highlighted operational partnership
Tata Sons (Air India owner) Coordinating with SIA and regulators, focused on crisis management and investigation
Indian Government/DGCA Leading investigation, enhancing regulatory oversight, prioritizing passenger safety and communication
Singapore Government Expressed official condolences, solidarity with India

What This Means for the Future of Indian Aviation

The Air India Flight AI171 disaster has exposed gaps in crisis communication and operational oversight in joint ventures involving foreign stakeholders. The public and regulatory response suggests that future policies will demand more transparency, accountability, and cooperation from all parties involved in Indian aviation.

For passengers, this could mean better communication during emergencies, more reliable safety checks, and improved service standards. For airlines and their foreign partners, the incident is a reminder that operational involvement comes with public responsibility, especially in times of crisis.

Practical Guidance for Affected Passengers and Families

If you or your family have been affected by the Air India Flight AI171 crash, here are some steps you can take:

  • Contact Air India’s official helpline for updates and support regarding compensation, travel arrangements, and counseling services. Visit www.airindia.com for contact details.
  • Monitor official updates from the Directorate General of Civil Aviation (www.dgca.gov.in) for information on ongoing investigations and safety measures.
  • Reach out to Singapore Airlines if you have questions about their involvement or support services: www.singaporeair.com.
  • Stay informed through trusted news sources and government announcements for the latest developments.

Conclusion: Lessons and Next Steps

The crash of Air India Flight AI171 has left a deep mark on Indian aviation and raised important questions about corporate responsibility, crisis communication, and the role of foreign stakeholders. As reported by VisaVerge.com, the incident is likely to lead to new rules and higher expectations for transparency and accountability in the industry.

Investigations are ongoing, and the findings will shape future policies and operational practices. For now, the focus remains on supporting affected families, ensuring passenger safety, and learning from this tragedy to prevent future disasters.

By staying informed and demanding accountability from all stakeholders, passengers and the public can help drive positive change in Indian aviation. The coming months will be critical as authorities, airlines, and their partners work together to rebuild trust and improve safety for everyone who flies.

Learn Today

Ram air turbine → Emergency device deploying to provide backup power during dual engine or major electrical failures.
Directorate General of Civil Aviation (DGCA) → India’s aviation regulator responsible for aircraft safety, surveillance, and regulatory enforcement.
Codeshare agreement → A partnership where airlines share flights and coordinate scheduling for operational efficiency.
Crisis communication → The timely and clear sharing of information during emergencies to manage public perception and response.
Privatization → The transfer of government-owned assets or companies to private ownership and management.

This Article in a Nutshell

On June 12, 2025, Air India Flight AI171 tragically crashed after takeoff from Ahmedabad, killing 241 onboard and 29 on the ground. Singapore Airlines’ delayed response, owning 25.1% of Air India, sparked criticism. Investigations and increased Boeing 787 safety checks followed, highlighting urgent aviation oversight reforms in India.
— By VisaVerge.com

Share This Article
Shashank Singh
Breaking News Reporter
Follow:
As a Breaking News Reporter at VisaVerge.com, Shashank Singh is dedicated to delivering timely and accurate news on the latest developments in immigration and travel. His quick response to emerging stories and ability to present complex information in an understandable format makes him a valuable asset. Shashank's reporting keeps VisaVerge's readers at the forefront of the most current and impactful news in the field.
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments