(UNITED STATES) The United States is facing a historic labor shortage, with an estimated gap of about one million workers as of August 2025. This shortfall is hitting key industries like construction, health care, and agriculture especially hard. At the center of this crisis is the country’s immigration policy, which has become more restrictive under the current administration. Rebecca Shi, Executive Director of the American Business Immigration Coalition, warns that these policies are making the economic situation worse, threatening growth and the ability of businesses to find the workers they need.
Labor Shortage by the Numbers: How Big Is the Problem?
The scale of the labor shortage is staggering. As of January 2025, there are 31.7 million immigrant workers in the United States 🇺🇸, making up nearly 20% of the total workforce—the highest share ever recorded. Despite this, the country is still short about a million workers, and the problem is expected to grow if current trends continue.
Let’s look at how this shortage affects different industries:
- 🏗️ Construction: The industry is projected to be short 500,000 workers in 2025. Immigrants make up over 25% of all construction workers. Without them, building homes, offices, and infrastructure would slow down even more.
- 🏥 Health Care: By 2036, the health care sector is expected to be short 135,000 workers. Immigrants currently fill 15.6% of nursing jobs and 28% of health-care aide positions.
- 🌾 Agriculture: Over 25% of agricultural workers are immigrants, and more than 54% of graders and sorters—the people who make sure our food is safe and ready to eat—are foreign-born.
- 🏡 Home Care: The U.S. is projected to be short 4.6 million home care workers by 2032. Immigrants are already a major part of this workforce, and without them, the shortage would be even worse.
These numbers show that immigrant workers are not just a small part of the economy—they are essential to keeping it running.
Recent Policy Changes: What’s Happening Now?
In January 2025, President Trump began his second term and quickly signed a series of executive orders that changed the country’s approach to immigration. These new rules are designed to increase enforcement, limit who can come to the United States 🇺🇸, and make it harder for people already here to stay.
Some of the biggest changes include:
- 🚨 Mass Deportations: The administration’s plan, known as Project 2025, aims to deport up to 4 million people over four years. This would be the largest removal effort in U.S. history.
- 🛑 Ending Protections: Programs that protect certain groups—like Dreamers (young people brought to the U.S. as children), Temporary Protected Status (TPS) holders, and other humanitarian programs—are being eliminated.
- ⚡ Faster Removals: The government is expanding “expedited removal,” which means people can be deported quickly, often without a chance to see a judge.
- 💻 Mandatory E-Verify: All employers must now use E-Verify, an online system that checks if new hires are allowed to work in the U.S. Critics say the system has a high error rate and could keep eligible workers from getting jobs.
- 👨👩👧👦 Family-Based Immigration Cuts: The administration is cutting back on family-based immigration and ending the Diversity Visa Lottery, which gives people from underrepresented countries a chance to come to the United States 🇺🇸. The focus is shifting to a “merit-based” system that favors certain skills and education.
- ⛔ Suspension of Refugee Admissions: As of January 27, 2025, the U.S. Refugee Admissions Program is suspended indefinitely, with only a few exceptions allowed due to ongoing court cases.
These changes have sparked heated debate among business leaders, workers, and advocacy groups.
Economic Impact: What Do These Policies Mean for Jobs and Businesses?
The effects of these new immigration policies are already being felt across the country. If the administration’s plan to deport 4 million people goes forward, experts predict the loss of nearly 6 million jobs—including 3.3 million jobs held by immigrants and 2.6 million jobs held by U.S.-born workers. This is because many businesses rely on immigrant workers to keep their doors open, and when those workers leave, the businesses often have to cut other jobs as well.
Here’s how different sectors could be affected:
- 🏗️ Construction: Could see an 18.8% drop in employment. This would slow down building projects, raise costs, and make it harder for people to find affordable housing.
- 👶 Child Care: Could lose 15.1% of its workforce, making it even harder for families to find care for their children.
- 🌱 Agriculture: Farms are already struggling to find enough workers. Some states report food rotting in the fields because there aren’t enough people to pick it.
- 🏨 Hospitality and Health Care: Hotels, restaurants, and hospitals are also having trouble finding and keeping workers, leading to higher prices and longer wait times for services.
Employers in these industries say the labor shortage is making it hard to keep up with demand. Some have even had to turn away business or close their doors because they can’t find enough staff.
The Role of Immigrants in Entrepreneurship
Immigrants are not just workers—they are also job creators. According to analysis by VisaVerge.com, one in five new business owners in the United States 🇺🇸 is an immigrant. In 2022, these businesses generated $110 billion in revenue. Without immigrants, the country would lose a major source of new jobs and innovation.
Stakeholder Perspectives: What Are People Saying?
Business and Industry Leaders
Groups like the American Business Immigration Coalition, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, and major associations in agriculture and health care have warned that restrictive immigration policies threaten economic growth. They say these rules will make the labor shortage worse, drive up prices, and make it harder to care for the country’s aging population.
Rebecca Shi, Executive Director of the American Business Immigration Coalition, has been especially vocal. She says,
“We’re short about a million workers. If we don’t fix our immigration policy, businesses will suffer, families will pay more, and our economy will slow down.”
Labor and Civil Rights Groups
Unions and advocacy organizations are also worried. They argue that mass deportations and the expansion of E-Verify will hurt communities of color, separate families, and create fear among workers. This fear can keep people from reporting abuse or seeking help when they need it.
A spokesperson for a major labor union said,
“These policies don’t just hurt immigrants—they hurt all workers. When people are afraid, they’re less likely to stand up for their rights.”
Trump Administration and Supporters
The administration argues that these policies are needed to protect American workers, reduce crime, and keep the country safe. Supporters say that by limiting immigration, wages for U.S.-born workers will go up and jobs will be more available.
However, many economists and business leaders disagree, saying that the real problem is not too many workers, but too few.
Procedural Details and Legal Challenges
The new rules are not just tough—they are also complicated. As of April 11, 2025, some immigrants must register with the government or face penalties. Employers must use E-Verify for all new hires, and those who don’t comply can face heavy fines.
Many of these executive orders are being challenged in court. For example, some rules about birthright citizenship and refugee admissions have been blocked by federal judges, at least for now. Humanitarian programs like DACA and TPS are being phased out or suspended, putting hundreds of thousands of people at risk of losing their right to work and facing deportation.
For those affected, the situation is confusing and stressful. Many don’t know if they will be able to stay in the country, keep their jobs, or support their families.
Historical Context: Why Does the U.S. Need Immigrant Workers?
The United States 🇺🇸 has a long history of relying on immigrants to fill jobs and keep the economy growing. As the native-born population ages and birth rates fall, there are fewer young people entering the workforce. Immigrants help fill this gap, taking jobs in industries that struggle to attract enough U.S.-born workers.
In the past, immigration policy has shifted to meet the country’s needs. For example, after World War II, the U.S. welcomed millions of immigrants to help rebuild the economy. In recent decades, immigrants have played a key role in sectors like technology, health care, and agriculture.
Now, with the country facing a severe labor shortage, many experts say that welcoming more immigrants—not fewer—is the best way to keep the economy strong.
Future Outlook: What Happens Next?
The future of U.S. immigration policy is uncertain. Legal battles over the administration’s executive orders are ongoing, and the outcome will shape the country’s labor market for years to come.
If current trends continue, the labor shortage is likely to get worse. Health care, agriculture, construction, and other essential sectors could see even bigger gaps, leading to higher prices, slower growth, and more stress on families and businesses.
Some experts warn that the country’s ability to compete globally could suffer. As other countries welcome skilled workers and entrepreneurs, the United States 🇺🇸 risks falling behind.
Solution-Oriented Approaches: What Can Be Done?
Many business leaders, economists, and advocates are calling for solutions that balance security with economic needs. Here are some ideas being discussed:
- 🔄 Modernize Immigration Policy: Update the system to allow more workers in sectors with shortages, such as health care, agriculture, and construction.
- 🛡️ Protect Dreamers and TPS Holders: Give legal status to people who have lived and worked in the U.S. for years, so they can continue contributing to the economy.
- ⚙️ Streamline Work Visas: Make it easier for employers to hire the workers they need, while protecting U.S.-born workers from unfair competition.
- 📚 Invest in Training: Help both immigrants and U.S.-born workers gain the skills needed for today’s jobs.
- 📝 Fix E-Verify: Improve the system to reduce errors and make sure eligible workers are not wrongly denied jobs.
Rebecca Shi and other advocates argue that these steps would help close the labor gap, support economic growth, and keep families together.
Case Study: The Impact on a Small Business
Consider a small construction company in Texas. The owner, Maria, employs 30 workers, 10 of whom are immigrants. With the new rules, she worries that some of her workers could be deported or lose their work permits. She has already had trouble finding enough people to fill open positions.
Maria says,
“If I lose even a few workers, I’ll have to turn down jobs. That means less income for my business and higher prices for my customers. I just want to follow the law and keep my business running, but the rules keep changing.”
Stories like Maria’s are playing out across the country, from farms in California to hospitals in New York. The uncertainty is making it hard for businesses to plan for the future.
Practical Guidance for Employers and Workers
For employers:
- 📋 Stay Informed: Keep up with the latest rules from U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The official USCIS website provides updates on forms, deadlines, and requirements: https://www.uscis.gov/
- 📋 Use E-Verify Carefully: Make sure your HR team understands how to use E-Verify and what to do if there’s a problem. Double-check any “tentative non-confirmations” before taking action.
- 📋 Consult Legal Experts: If you’re unsure about the rules, talk to an immigration lawyer or a trusted advisor.
For workers:
- 📋 Know Your Rights: If you’re affected by new policies, learn about your rights and options. Organizations like the American Immigration Lawyers Association offer resources and support.
- 📋 Keep Documents Updated: Make sure your work permits, visas, and other documents are current. If you need to renew or apply for a new form, start early.
- 📋 Seek Help if Needed: If you’re facing deportation or losing your work authorization, reach out to advocacy groups or legal aid organizations for help.
Broader Social Implications: Families and Communities
The impact of these policies goes beyond the workplace. Families are being separated, children are growing up in fear, and entire communities are feeling the strain. When workers are forced to leave, neighborhoods lose not just employees, but friends, neighbors, and community leaders.
Schools, churches, and local businesses all feel the effects. In some areas, population decline is leading to school closures and fewer services. In others, the loss of workers is making it harder to care for the elderly and sick.
Expert Analysis: What Do Economists Say?
Most economists and demographers agree that immigration is essential for the U.S. economy, especially as the population ages. They warn that restrictive policies could make the labor shortage worse, drive up costs, and hurt the country’s ability to compete with other nations.
A recent report from a leading economic think tank found that
“without immigrants, the U.S. will struggle to fill key jobs, keep prices stable, and support an aging population.”
The report also noted that immigrants are more likely to start businesses, create jobs, and pay taxes than many people realize.
Legal Resources and Official Information
For those seeking more information or needing to take action, several official resources are available:
- 📝 U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS): The main government agency for immigration forms, updates, and guidance. https://www.uscis.gov/
- 📊 U.S. Department of Labor: Information on labor laws, worker protections, and employment data. https://www.dol.gov/
- 🤝 American Business Immigration Coalition: Advocacy and resources for employers and workers. https://www.americanbic.biz/
- ⚖️ American Immigration Lawyers Association: Legal updates, advocacy, and support for immigrants. https://www.aila.org/
Conclusion: The Road Ahead
The United States 🇺🇸 is at a crossroads. The current labor shortage is putting pressure on businesses, families, and communities across the country. Immigration policy is at the heart of the debate, with new rules threatening to make the problem worse.
Rebecca Shi and other experts warn that unless the country finds a way to welcome and support immigrant workers, the economy will suffer, prices will rise, and families will be torn apart. The choices made in the coming months and years will shape the future of the country’s workforce, economy, and society.
For now, the best advice is to stay informed, seek help when needed, and support policies that recognize the vital role immigrants play in keeping the United States 🇺🇸 strong and prosperous. As the debate continues, one thing is clear: the country’s future depends on finding solutions that work for everyone.
Action Steps for Readers
- ✅ Employers: Review your hiring practices, stay updated on immigration rules, and support efforts to modernize immigration policy.
- ✅ Workers: Keep your documents current, know your rights, and seek help if you face challenges.
- ✅ Community Members: Support local businesses, welcome newcomers, and advocate for fair and practical immigration solutions.
The labor shortage is a challenge, but with smart policies and a commitment to fairness, the United States 🇺🇸 can build a stronger, more inclusive future for all.
This Article in a Nutshell
