Eluned Morgan rejects Keir Starmer’s divisive immigration rhetoric

Key Takeaways

• Eluned Morgan rejects divisive language, contrasting Welsh Labour’s stance with Keir Starmer’s tougher immigration proposals.
• UK’s new White Paper raises settlement to 10 years, closes care worker visas, and increases salary and English requirements.
• Key Labour and Green figures criticize Starmer’s “island of strangers” remark, recalling Enoch Powell’s divisive 1968 speech.

Welsh First Minister Eluned Morgan has stepped into the center of the ongoing immigration debate in the United Kingdom 🇬🇧, openly rejecting what she calls “divisive language” from the top level of government. Her clear stance draws a line between Welsh Labour’s approach to immigration and recent language and policy proposals from Prime Minister Keir Starmer. This disagreement is about more than just words. It marks a deep split in how different political leaders view newcomers and the rules that shape the future of immigration across the country.

A Sharp Reaction to Changing Immigration Rules

The spark for Eluned Morgan’s strong comments was the announcement of a new immigration White Paper by the government in Westminster, led by Prime Minister Keir Starmer. The details of this plan would make some of the most sweeping changes to immigration law Britain has seen in years. Here’s what the new proposals include:

• Raising the settlement waiting time: People will need to live in the UK 🇬🇧 for ten years, instead of just five, before they can apply to remain permanently.
• Tougher skilled worker rules: You’ll need at least a bachelor’s degree to qualify for a skilled worker visa. This excludes many people who might otherwise fill crucial jobs.
• Closing care worker visas: Recruitment from overseas for care jobs would end, shutting out a key source of staff for a sector that relies heavily on immigrants.
• Higher hurdles for pay and language skills: The new plan also increases salary and English language requirements, making it harder for people to come and work in the UK 🇬🇧.

When announcing these measures, Keir Starmer warned that “Britain risks becoming an ‘island of strangers’ because of high levels of immigration.” Many politicians and community leaders reacted quickly—some noting that the phrase reminded them of Enoch Powell’s infamous 1968 “Rivers of Blood” speech, which is widely viewed as stoking fear and division about immigration.

Eluned Morgan Stands Apart

During a session of the Senedd, which is the Welsh Parliament, Eluned Morgan made her view very clear. She said:

“I’m not going to use divisive language when it comes to immigration, that’s not the value we have in Welsh Labour. We are committed to ensuring that we do our best to provide a care service in Wales. That will be more difficult if it is not possible to hire people from abroad.”

With these words, Eluned Morgan’s position stood out sharply from the comments and language used in Westminster. She pointed to a simple but powerful fact: many essential workers in Wales, especially in the care sector, come from overseas. If rules become too tight, then Wales may struggle to look after elderly or vulnerable people. Her message was, at its heart, about looking after people and making sure that public services can continue to function.

Rather than treating newcomers in a negative or suspicious way, Eluned Morgan said that Welsh Labour values fairness and inclusion. Her main point was that cutting off immigration will harm Wales in practical ways, especially for public services that depend on staff from outside the country.

This isn’t just a political disagreement—it shows a real difference in what leaders think is most important: harsh rules or support for communities.

How Other Politicians and Groups Responded

Eluned Morgan is not alone in her view. Other leaders inside and outside Labour have also spoken out against the language used by Keir Starmer. For example:

• London Mayor Sadiq Khan said he would not have used the words chosen by Prime Minister Keir Starmer.
• Various Labour MPs called the “island of strangers” line shameful, and some compared it to Enoch Powell’s words from decades earlier.
• Refugee charities and Green Party leader Caroline Lucas also condemned the language, saying that it fuels fear about migrants.
• Even with the backlash, Keir Starmer stood firm. He rejected comparisons between his comments and Powell’s speech but said he would keep pushing for stricter immigration rules, while also praising the contributions of immigrants to the UK 🇬🇧.

As reported by VisaVerge.com, these splits show that the UK 🇬🇧 Labour Party faces tough choices on how to move forward. There is strong support in some areas for making immigration rules tougher, but many members and leaders believe the focus should be on kindness, fairness, and supporting key public services.

Looking Deeper: What Do the Changes Really Mean?

It’s important to think about what these new immigration policies could mean for ordinary people and the wider society.

For Employers and the Economy

• Care homes and hospitals: Many care workers in Britain are immigrants. Shutting down overseas recruitment will make it much harder to find enough staff, especially as the population ages.
• Other industries: Raising the bar for skilled worker visas limits the number of people who can come to work in sectors like hospitality, manufacturing, or retail. Some businesses may not be able to fill all their roles.

For Immigrants and Their Families

• Longer settlement time: People who plan to make the UK 🇬🇧 their home now have to wait twice as long, with more uncertainty during that period.
• Higher pay and skill demands: Many are shut out of jobs they could do, simply because new rules demand degrees or higher pay than some roles offer.
• Language requirements: While good communication helps, stricter language rules can block even those willing to work hard and contribute.

For Public Services

Public services like healthcare and social care often depend on staff from abroad. If the government makes it too difficult for these workers to come to the UK 🇬🇧, these services could face staff shortages. This is especially serious in places like Wales, where there’s already a struggle to find enough workers.

For Local Communities

Communities that have welcomed immigrants benefit from the arrival of people with new skills and experiences. When leaders use harsh words, this can make immigrants feel unwelcome and make it harder for everyone to get along.

Divisive Language: Why Does It Matter?

The words politicians use can change the mood of a whole country. When leaders talk about immigrants in a way that singles them out or suggests they don’t belong, it can:

• Encourage suspicion and fear among people who might otherwise welcome newcomers
• Make it harder for immigrants to feel part of their new community
• Spark divisions, rather than bringing people together

Eluned Morgan’s decision to reject this sort of language is more than just a statement for the record. By calling out divisive language, she hopes to set a better example—one that is kinder, more open, and more in line with Welsh values.

Why Is Inclusive Language Important?

Using language that welcomes everyone helps create communities where people feel safe and valued. Simple, inclusive language can:

• Make sure everyone—no matter where they come from—feels like they belong
• Help communities stay strong, showing that differences can be strengths
• Encourage skilled people to come and work in essential jobs, knowing they’ll be respected and supported

The Wider Debate in the Labour Party

The discussion sparked by Eluned Morgan’s comments opens up a larger debate inside the Labour Party as well as across the UK 🇬🇧. There’s a split between those who think stricter immigration rules are needed and those who say the real priority should be caring for people and supporting public services.

Some party members want to show that Labour can be tough on immigration—often to win support from voters who are worried about change. Others, like Eluned Morgan, stress the real-life impacts of harsh rules, especially for people who are already working hard and for services that desperately need staff.

The words of Keir Starmer signal a direction toward more control. But the reaction of leaders like Eluned Morgan shows that there is real disagreement about the best way to manage immigration—not just as a set of laws and rules, but as a question of what sort of country the UK 🇬🇧 wants to be.

A Quick Look at Key Positions

To help make sense of where everyone stands, here’s a summary:

These differences may seem subtle at first. But in politics, the way leaders talk about issues can shape the policies that follow, and can change how people act towards one another every day.

Balancing Border Control With Human Needs

Most people agree that every country needs clear rules to decide who can come and live or work there. But there’s a careful balance to be struck:

• Too open, and there may be pressure on services or jobs.
• Too strict, and public services might struggle for staff, families could be kept apart, and communities may become less welcoming.

Eluned Morgan’s comments call for a careful middle ground. She wants clear rules, but also flexibility—especially where immigrants fill vital roles. She also stresses the need for debate that avoids anger, blame, or fear.

The Historical Echo: Why Enoch Powell Is Still Mentioned

Whenever politicians use strong words about immigration, old wounds can reopen. In 1968, Enoch Powell gave a speech that has never been forgotten, where he warned of terrible outcomes from mass immigration. The language he used was seen as stirring up hate and division, rather than offering solutions.

When Keir Starmer used the phrase “island of strangers,” many people immediately thought of Powell’s speech. The comparison is powerful because it reminds everyone how important it is for public figures to be careful with their words. Even if Starmer did not intend the same message, the echo was strong enough to draw widespread criticism.

The Welsh Difference: A Separate Identity in the Debate

Wales has a long history of welcoming people from all over the world. Many in Wales, including Eluned Morgan, believe that this openness is part of what makes the country strong. By setting herself apart from tougher language and policies coming from Westminster, Morgan aims to defend a sense of unity and kindness that she views as uniquely Welsh.

A commitment to good public services, fair treatment for all, and respect for immigrants are values that Eluned Morgan says matter most—values she sees as being distinct from recent moves in the UK 🇬🇧 as a whole.

What Comes Next?

The debate about immigration in the UK 🇬🇧 is not about to end anytime soon. As the government considers putting these new rules into practice, many groups—employers, families, community leaders, and politicians—will keep speaking up about what matters most to them.

If you want to see the exact details of the new White Paper or keep up with official updates, you can visit the UK Government’s official immigration policy page.

In Summary

Eluned Morgan has made her stance clear—rejecting divisive language and shining a spotlight on Wales’ need for fair, balanced immigration policies that keep essential services running and make everyone feel included. Her words have started a wider discussion, not just about the rules, but about the sort of country the UK 🇬🇧 should be. With opposing approaches within Labour itself, led by Keir Starmer on one side and voices like Morgan’s on the other, much will depend on which vision gains the most support as the country’s immigration laws continue to change.

As this story develops, expect more debate about the words leaders use and the real impact their choices have on communities across the United Kingdom 🇬🇧.

Learn Today

White Paper → A government policy document outlining proposed legislation or reforms, inviting debate and feedback before becoming law.
Settlement Waiting Time → The minimum period a migrant must legally reside before qualifying to apply for permanent residence.
Skilled Worker Visa → A permit allowing foreign nationals to work in the UK in recognized, qualified roles meeting education and salary criteria.
Care Worker Visa → A specific visa route that permits foreign care professionals to be recruited by UK health and social care employers.
Divisive Language → Political speech or rhetoric that separates, excludes, or stokes antagonism toward particular groups within society.

This Article in a Nutshell

Welsh First Minister Eluned Morgan openly challenges divisive immigration rhetoric, highlighting deep splits with UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer. New government reforms will tighten settlement, skilled worker, and care worker visa rules. Morgan urges inclusive policies to maintain essential public services and emphasizes why language toward immigrants shapes national unity and community resilience.
— By VisaVerge.com

Read more:

• Immigration Policies Limit NCAA NIL Deals for International Student-Athletes
• Arizona Governor Hobbs blocks hospitals from checking immigration status
• American Children Deported After Immigration Arrests on the Hi-Line
• Block Club Chicago sues ICE over Chicago immigration arrest records
• Understanding the June 2025 Visa Bulletin: A Guide to U.S. Immigration Policies