Quebec seeks federal cut in immigration levels

Key Takeaways

• Quebec demands federal immigration cuts, targeting temporary residents like foreign workers, students, and asylum seekers.
• Quebec paused invitations for key immigration programs and requires stronger French language skills for applicants.
• Business leaders warn limiting immigration will worsen labor shortages and negatively impact Quebec’s economy and essential services.

Quebec 🇨🇦 has taken a bold step by asking the next federal government to cut immigration, especially when it comes to temporary residents like foreign workers, international students, and asylum seekers. This request has brought out strong reactions from businesses and has started an important debate across the province and the country. Quebec’s push has big effects not just for immigrants, but also for workers, employers, students, and the many people who depend on a steady flow of people moving into the province. As reported by VisaVerge.com, these competing views between government leaders and the business sector are leading to one of the most important discussions about Canada 🇨🇦’s future immigration path.

Quebec’s Stand on Immigration Cuts

In recent months, Quebec’s government has made its feelings clear: too many people coming in through temporary immigration programs is causing problems for everyone. Premier François Legault has said the current approach to temporary immigration cannot go on. He even threatened to hold a referendum, which is a public vote, if Ottawa does not act to limit these numbers.

The main reasons the government gives are simple, but serious. Quebec says that there are now about 560,000 non-permanent (temporary) immigrants in the province, a number that covers people who are living and working in Quebec but have not yet become permanent residents. The government claims this jump in newcomers has made it harder to provide everyone with basic services. For example, schools are crowded, health care wait times are up, and rents are rising too fast. The Premier and his team argue that the growth in the population is just too fast for Quebec to handle.

Quebec’s 2025 Immigration Plan spells out their proposed approach:
– Quebec wants between 48,500 and 51,500 new permanent residents in 2025, which is about the same as previous years.
– The “Québec graduate” stream of the Québec Experience Program (PEQ) has been paused. (The Québec Experience Program is a special program that helps certain temporary residents, such as international students and skilled workers, become permanent residents more quickly. The “Québec graduate” stream let Quebec-trained students apply, but this path is now on hold.)
– Quebec stopped sending out invitations for both its Regular Skilled Worker Program (RSWP) and the new program supposed to replace it. This pause will last until at least June 30, 2025.
– The plan puts a strong focus on making sure French language skills are at the center of all immigration programs.
– Quebec also wants the federal government to send fewer asylum seekers (people asking for protection) to the province.
– The government is asking Ottawa for more power to control how immigrants—especially temporary ones—are picked.

With these measures, Quebec makes clear it wants to control how many people arrive, how quickly they come, and how well they speak French. The province’s leaders believe this is the only way to keep up with basic needs and protect the French language in Quebec.

Impact on Business and the Labor Market

Business leaders strongly disagree with the idea of lowering immigration, especially with the plan to limit temporary residents. Employer groups argue that these big changes are not driven by real data, but by politics. They worry that if Quebec gets its way and the federal government starts cutting back, many businesses will struggle even more to find workers.

Their concerns are based on real facts:
– Quebec has an older population, and more people are retiring every year than young people entering the workforce. For every ten workers leaving, only about eight people come to fill those jobs. Immigration is the main way to fill that gap.
– Without enough new workers, businesses will have to slow down, turn down work, or even close. This can mean fewer goods and services and higher prices for everyone.
– Some specific sectors—like farming, health care, and construction—depend a lot on workers from other countries. When these workers can’t come, jobs go unfilled and companies might pull out of the province.

Karl Blackburn from the Conseil du patronat du Québec (the province’s main employer group) summed it up simply: “Their numbers… reflect the needs of the labour market and of an aging society.” Employers say the flow of immigrants matches what is needed to keep Quebec’s economy running. They also say that the real problems—like school overcrowding or not enough funding for hospitals and houses—are not the fault of immigrants, but of the policies and budgets set by the government. Blackburn added, “It’s as if our governments knowingly agreed to cause companies to lose contracts for reasons of political partisanship…”

The Business View in Detail

Employers list several points and warnings:
– Labor shortages are already bad in Quebec, and with more people retiring, things will get worse if fewer immigrants can come.
– Immigrants keep key industries running, such as agriculture and healthcare.
– Temporary foreign workers help out in places where Canadians 🇨🇦 cannot be found, even with good pay and benefits.
– Blaming immigrants for things like high rents or long waits at emergency rooms means we are looking at the wrong problems.

In their view, Quebec needs more, not fewer, temporary workers. They say the current system is not “flooding” the province, but meeting real needs in the labor market. The groups warn that cutting back too hard could cause factories to stop running, construction to slow down, and important services to lose workers. This could touch almost everyone in Quebec, from consumers who rely on stores and groceries, to companies trying to grow.

What Happens to Programs Like Québec Experience Program?

One of the biggest changes in Quebec’s 2025 plan is stopping the “Québec graduate” part of the Québec Experience Program. This program is a pathway that makes it easier for certain temporary residents to become permanent residents if they have studied or worked in Quebec. In the past, international students who had studied in Quebec could apply through this path.

Now, that option is suspended. This means many students and skilled temporary workers in Quebec might have a harder time becoming permanent residents in the near future. Only those who already submitted their application before the pause can keep going in the process for now. This change could make Quebec less attractive to international students, who often hope to live and work in Quebec after graduating.

It should be noted that application rules can change. To see the latest details about programs, including the Québec Experience Program, the official Quebec immigration website is the best place to check. This site lists which streams are open, who can apply, and current requirements around things like French language skills.

How Do Politics and Government Powers Shape This Disagreement?

Canada 🇨🇦’s immigration system involves both the federal government in Ottawa and provinces like Quebec. Under an agreement called the Canada–Quebec Accord, Quebec can pick most of its new immigrants and set the rules for selection, especially for language. But the federal government still controls who enters the country and who gets things like work permits and visas.

Recently, Ottawa responded to some worries about the overall size of the program by lowering its national target for new permanent residents. The federal government said it will cut planned additions by about 21 percent over three years, from 395,000 people in 2025 downwards. However, this move does not directly answer what Quebec wants: a major drop in temporary workers and more powers to limit asylum seekers.

This creates a situation where federal cuts might not make a big difference for Quebec, especially if the province cannot get more say over programs for temporary workers, students, and refugees.

Political Parties: A Table of Positions

Here’s a brief look at what key parties or groups are saying about this issue, at both the federal and provincial levels:

This table shows how multi-layered the debate is and why a simple answer will be hard to find. Quebec’s government says the top priority is slowing down arrivals to relieve the pressure on schools, hospitals, and the French language. Businesses, meanwhile, say the priority should be meeting labor shortages and keeping the economy from shrinking.

What Does This Mean for Immigrants, Employers, and the Public?

For people looking to move to Quebec, the pause on some immigration programs and the new French requirements will make things slower and harder. Workers and students who would normally use the Québec Experience Program may need to find new paths or wait for the process to restart. Employers may see even longer gaps between job openings and qualified candidates. The public might notice longer wait times and higher prices if companies cannot find enough workers.

Employers also warn that if Quebec becomes less friendly to newcomers, some businesses might move to other provinces or even out of the country. Students from outside Canada 🇨🇦 considering where to study could pick other provinces instead of Quebec if they see fewer pathways to stay.

However, supporters of Quebec’s plan say more control is needed to protect the French language and to make sure the province can support people who already live there. They think the government’s approach will benefit the province in the long run by preventing over-crowding and helping people fit in better.

Summary Table: Different Priorities

Where Things Stand Now

The back-and-forth between lowering immigration as Quebec wants, and keeping it steady or raising it as businesses want, shows the real tension between different goals. One side sees the need to slow down in order to keep French strong and services running; the other sees the risk of greater economic pain if companies cannot staff up and grow.

What happens next will depend on the federal government’s response and on how tough Quebec stays in pushing for change. For now, international students, temporary workers, and businesses will have to wait and see which path the province and Ottawa choose.

For the latest official information on programs like the Québec Experience Program, language rules, and current immigration plans, the Quebec government’s immigration site is the best place to visit.

As this debate continues, it’s clear that the choices made in Quebec will help shape not just the province’s future, but Canada 🇨🇦’s approach to immigration as a whole. Whether you are an immigrant, an employer, or part of the general public, these decisions will affect everyday life, the economy, and what it means to call Quebec home.

Learn Today

Temporary Residents → Individuals living and working in Quebec temporarily, such as foreign workers, students, and asylum seekers, without permanent resident status.
Québec Experience Program (PEQ) → A provincial immigration program offering pathways to permanent residence for international students and skilled workers in Quebec.
Non-Permanent Immigrants → People residing in Quebec on temporary visas or permits who have not obtained permanent residency.
Canada–Quebec Accord → An agreement granting Quebec authority to select most immigrants and set language requirements, while federal government controls entry and status.
Asylum Seekers → Individuals requesting protection and permission to stay in a country due to threats or dangerous conditions in their home country.

This Article in a Nutshell

Quebec’s government urges dramatic immigration cuts, especially for temporary residents, citing strains on services and French language protection. Businesses fiercely oppose, highlighting existing labor shortages. As federal and provincial positions diverge, immigrants, employers, and students face uncertainty about Quebec’s future pathways. The outcome will shape both provincial and national immigration policies.
— By VisaVerge.com

Read more:

• Official Government Forms for Visas, Immigration, and Travel
• Idaho focuses on immigration with new bills in 2025 session
• Indiana Legislature passes key immigration cooperation bill
• Canadian immigration policies urged to welcome US healthcare pros
• Biden administration faces claims of missed immigration court dates