(SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA) Calls to stop ICE arrests at immigration hearings have grown louder across Southern California after a federal court issued temporary restraining orders in July 2025. These orders block Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents from making stops and arrests at or near immigration courts without clear legal reasons. The court’s decision comes after months of community protests, legal challenges, and reports of immigrants being detained while trying to follow the law.
The restraining orders, issued by U.S. District Judge Maame Ewusi-Mensah Frimpong, mark a turning point for immigrants in Southern California. The orders state that ICE agents cannot arrest people based on vague reasons like speaking Spanish or simply being present in certain areas. Instead, agents must have “reasonable suspicion”—a clear, legal reason—before stopping or arresting anyone. The court also requires ICE to let detained immigrants speak with their lawyers at all times, even on weekends and holidays, at places like the B-18 federal building in downtown Los Angeles.
Legal Rulings and Immediate Impact
The government quickly appealed these restraining orders, hoping to pause them while the case moves forward. However, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals denied the request, meaning the restrictions on ICE arrests remain in place for now. This decision is seen as a major win for immigrant rights groups, who have argued that ICE arrests at immigration hearings are unfair and often violate basic rights.
According to analysis by VisaVerge.com, the court’s actions have already changed how ICE operates in the region. ICE agents can no longer make arrests at or near immigration hearings without strong evidence. This change is meant to protect people who are attending court to follow immigration law, not to hide from it.
Community Response and Advocacy
Community groups, including the ACLU of Southern California, the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA), and Immigrant Justice, have pushed hard for these changes. They say that ICE arrests at immigration hearings scare people away from court, making it harder for them to defend themselves or fix their immigration status.
“People should not have to choose between following the law and risking arrest,” said a spokesperson for CHIRLA.
Local governments, such as the City and County of Los Angeles and the State of California, have also joined the fight. They argue that ICE’s actions have violated the constitutional rights of residents and created fear in neighborhoods. These governments have supported lawsuits and provided legal help to those affected.
ICE’s Position and Ongoing Debate
ICE and the Department of Justice defend their actions by saying they are focused on public safety and only target people with criminal records or those who have broken immigration laws. They claim that their agents act within the law and have the right to make arrests when they have reasonable suspicion. However, the courts have found that some of ICE’s practices—like not showing arrest warrants or failing to explain why someone is being detained—do not meet legal standards.
The debate continues over how to balance immigration enforcement with the need to protect people’s rights. Some believe that strong enforcement is needed to keep communities safe, while others say that targeting people at immigration hearings is unfair and discourages them from following the law.
Statistical Trends and Enforcement Data
Recent data shows that ICE arrests have dropped sharply since the court orders took effect.
| Month | ICE Arrests per Day | Change (%) | Removals (Deportations) per Day | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| June 2025 | 1,224 | — | — | — |
| July 2025 | 990 | -19.1% | +84 | Increase |
This drop is linked to both public backlash and the new legal limits on ICE operations. However, the number of removals, or deportations, actually rose slightly, with an average of 84 more people deported each day in July compared to June.
These numbers suggest that while ICE is making fewer arrests, it is still removing people from the United States 🇺🇸 at a steady pace. The Trump administration, which has pushed for tougher immigration enforcement, has not met its previous goals for daily arrests. Legal challenges and public protests have made it harder for ICE to carry out large-scale raids, especially in places like Southern California where local governments offer strong protections for immigrants.
How ICE Arrests Affect Immigrants and Their Families
For many immigrants, the threat of ICE arrests at immigration hearings creates fear and confusion. People who want to follow the law and attend their court dates worry that they might be detained just for showing up. This fear can lead some to skip hearings, which can hurt their cases and even lead to automatic removal orders.
The court’s restraining orders are designed to make the process fairer. By stopping ICE from making arrests without clear reasons, the court hopes to encourage people to attend their hearings and work with their lawyers. The orders also require ICE to let people talk to their lawyers at all times, which is important for building a strong defense.
One immigrant, who asked not to be named, shared, “I was afraid to go to my hearing because I heard ICE was waiting outside. Now, I feel safer knowing they can’t just arrest me for no reason.”
Background: How Did We Get Here?
ICE arrests at immigration hearings and in public places increased sharply in 2024 and early 2025. The Trump administration set higher targets for deportations and encouraged agents to make more arrests, even in places where immigrants were trying to follow the law. This led to reports of ICE agents not identifying themselves, failing to show arrest warrants, and making arrests based on language or appearance.
Advocacy groups and local governments responded with lawsuits and public protests. They argued that these tactics violated constitutional rights, including the right to due process and equal protection under the law. The courts agreed in several cases, leading to the current restraining orders and ongoing legal battles.
Federal court issued temporary restraining orders blocking ICE arrests at immigration courts
9th Circuit Court of Appeals denied government’s request to pause restraining orders
Upcoming court hearing regarding ICE arrests
ICE arrests at immigration hearings increased sharply
Trump administration set higher targets for deportations
What Happens Next?
The legal fight over ICE arrests at immigration hearings is far from over. The Trump administration and ICE have said they plan to appeal the court’s decisions, possibly all the way to the Supreme Court. They want to restore broader enforcement powers and remove the current limits on arrests.
At the same time, advocacy groups are pushing for permanent rules that would stop ICE from making arrests at immigration hearings without clear legal reasons. They hope that upcoming court hearings, like the one scheduled for September 24, 2025, will lead to lasting protections for immigrants.
Lawmakers at both the federal and state levels may also get involved. Some are considering new laws that would make it illegal for ICE to arrest people at or near immigration courts unless they have a valid warrant or clear evidence of wrongdoing.
Practical Steps for Immigrants and Families
If you or someone you know is worried about ICE arrests at immigration hearings, here are some steps you can take:
- 📋 Know your rights: You have the right to remain silent and to ask for a lawyer. ICE agents must show a valid warrant if they want to enter your home.
- 📋 Stay informed: Check for updates from trusted sources like the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) website or local immigrant rights groups.
- 📋 Get legal help: Organizations like the ACLU Southern California and Immigrant Justice offer free or low-cost legal assistance. They can help you understand your case and what to do if you are detained.
- 📋 Attend your hearings: If you have a court date, it is important to go. The new court orders make it safer to attend, and missing your hearing can hurt your case.
- 📋 Keep documents ready: Carry copies of important papers, such as your hearing notice, identification, and contact information for your lawyer.
Resources for Further Help
- ACLU Southern California
- Immigrant Justice
- U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS)
- Los Angeles County Office of Immigrant Affairs
These organizations provide updates, legal advice, and support for people affected by ICE enforcement.
Looking Ahead
The outcome of the ongoing court cases and possible new laws will shape how ICE arrests are handled at immigration hearings in the future. For now, the court’s restraining orders offer some protection for immigrants in Southern California, giving them a better chance to attend hearings and work with their lawyers without fear.
As the legal process continues, it is important for immigrants, families, and advocates to stay informed and connected to trusted resources. The fight over ICE arrests at immigration hearings is about more than just law enforcement—it is about fairness, safety, and the right to have your day in court.
This Article in a Nutshell
