Puntos Clave
• DeSantis propone delito estatal por presencia ilegal y endurece sanciones a autoridades que no cooperen.
• Una corte federal bloqueó parte clave de la ley SB 1718 en mayo de 2024, tras demandas de organizaciones.
• Se estima que la deportación masiva reduciría el PIB de Florida en 4.2%, perdiendo $1.9 mil millones en impuestos locales.
Florida’s Immigration Blueprint Under Governor Ron DeSantis: Legal, Economic, and Social Debate
Florida has become the center of a major debate in the United States 🇺🇸 regarding how states should deal with immigration. Governor Ron DeSantis has presented a set of tough proposals targeting undocumented immigrants, making Florida a key supporter of President Trump’s vision for immigration enforcement.
But while some believe these efforts strengthen public safety and uphold federal law, others argue the measures go too far, harming families, businesses, and possibly breaking constitutional rights. This article looks closely at the laws, the reactions from critics and supporters, and how these decisions could affect people across Florida.
Florida’s Push for Stricter Immigration Enforcement
In January 2025, Governor Ron DeSantis announced a detailed immigration plan in Winter Haven. He made it clear that he plans for Florida to “lead” in supporting the new administration’s focus on tough enforcement. He said, “Florida is ready to lead. With President Trump taking office, Florida has a unique opportunity to help facilitate the end to America’s immigration crisis.” (Source: FL Government Press Release).
Key proposals in the plan include:
- Making it a state crime to enter the country without legal status: This would mean people caught entering Florida illegally could face state-level criminal charges, not just federal immigration violations.
-
Self-Deportation Process: The proposal also introduces a process where undocumented people could be removed from the state more quickly.
-
Tough Penalties for Law Enforcement and Officials: Police officers could face criminal charges if they do not fully cooperate in immigration enforcement. Elected officials could even be charged with felonies for failing to comply.
-
More Local Officers Working with Immigration: At least 10% of every law enforcement agency’s workforce would receive training to help in identifying and processing undocumented immigrants for deportation.
-
Expanding Transport and Detention: The state would expand its current programs to detain and transport undocumented immigrants for removal.
-
Repealing Tuition Benefits: The plan would end in-state college tuition for undocumented students. That means students who grew up in Florida, but entered the country illegally, would pay much higher tuition or lose the chance to attend public colleges.
-
Making it Harder to Get Bail: The proposal creates a new rule presuming any undocumented immigrant is a “flight risk,” making it much harder for them to get bail in court.
Analysis from VisaVerge.com suggests that these proposals not only make Florida’s immigration laws among the toughest in the country but also set a model that other states might want to follow if they support similar policies.
Legal and Constitutional Concerns
While supporters of Ron DeSantis and these new laws argue that strict enforcement is needed for public safety, legal groups and immigration advocates insist the state is overstepping its power.
Court Challenges Already Underway
In May 2024, a federal judge temporarily blocked part of Florida’s Senate Bill 1718, especially a section called “Section 10.” This part made it illegal to transport undocumented immigrants into Florida. Groups like the ACLU, Americans for Immigrant Justice, and the American Immigration Council led the lawsuit.
They argued that the law threatened everyday activities, such as driving a relative to a doctor’s appointment, with criminal charges if that person was undocumented. The court agreed, at least for now, and stopped this rule from taking effect while the case continues. (Source: American Immigration Council news).
Emma Winger, deputy legal director of the American Immigration Council, spoke about the importance of the court ruling, saying, “This ruling means freedom from fear and increased safety for families and communities of color in Florida. As states across the country are increasingly passing unjust and unconstitutional laws that target people because of their immigration status, it’s critical that our courts set a precedent for protecting these families at risk.”
Who Controls Immigration?
A big question in this dispute is who gets to enforce immigration rules. The United States 🇺🇸 Constitution gives much of this power to the federal government, not states. But Ron DeSantis and his supporters say that when the federal government does not enforce the laws strongly enough, states like Florida can step up.
Opponents argue that by making immigration enforcement a state crime or forcing police to help with deportations, Florida is breaking federal rules and the Constitution. Many experts believe these legal battles could eventually reach the Supreme Court.
Concerns over Due Process
Critics point out that the immigration system is already complicated, and new laws may make things worse for people who are accused of being in the country illegally. Unlike criminal courts, the immigration court system operates under civil law. This means people can be detained for long periods, sometimes with no clear end date.
- No Right to Free Legal Help: Immigrants held in detention do not have a guaranteed right to a free lawyer, even if they cannot afford one.
- Faster Deportations, Less Review: Florida’s plan supports the use of “expedited removal” (fast-track deportation), where people arrested can be removed from the country quickly and may not get a hearing before a judge.
On January 22, 2025, the ACLU and other groups filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration for expanding these fast-track deportation policies without enough legal protections for those involved.
Anand Balakrishnan, senior staff attorney with the ACLU’s Immigrants’ Rights Project, explained the worries, “The Trump administration wants to use this illegal policy to fuel its mass deportation agenda and rip communities apart. Expanding expedited removal would give Trump a cheat code to circumvent due process and the Constitution, and we are again here to fight it.”
Impact on Florida’s Economy
Another main worry is how these changes could hurt Florida, especially its economy. Florida has one of the largest populations of undocumented immigrants in the country. A report by the American Immigration Council said that, if mass deportations happen, Florida would be one of the top three states most affected.
- Economic Loss: The country’s gross domestic product (GDP)—the measure of how much all goods and services are worth—could shrink by 4.2%. That’s a drop similar to what happened during the Great Recession.
-
Who Makes Up the Workforce? Many of the people who could be deported work in important jobs, including farming, construction, and tourism. Losing these workers suddenly could create shortages, driving prices higher and slowing Florida’s economy.
-
State and Local Taxes: In 2022, undocumented immigrants in Florida paid about $1.9 billion in state and local taxes. Losing these contributions would mean less money for schools, roads, and emergency services.
Rene Gomez, Civic Engagement Coordinator at the Farmworkers Association of Florida, described what could happen in key industries: “Our agriculture prices have already risen up. The vegetables, the fruits, anything that has to be picked by hand, that is only going to go higher. People think it’s bad now, but when you lose that workforce, and say you do replace them with citizens, a lot of these people that are getting paid are getting paid below minimum wage, so that’s only going to increase the prices for everyday Americans.”
The Pew Research Center estimates there were about 1.2 million undocumented immigrants living in Florida by 2022. Their work and spending power help many communities, from large cities to rural farming towns.
Communities, Families, and Everyday Life
Perhaps the most personal impact of the new laws and policies is on families and communities. Section 10 of SB 1718, which was blocked by the federal court, would have made it illegal for people to drive, help, or even shelter an undocumented immigrant. Parents could face charges for helping their own children or elderly parents with daily tasks.
For schools, hospitals, churches, and employers, these rules create confusion. Many worry about being criminally charged for offering basic help or services, and fear grows among immigrants—even those with legal status—who are unsure of their rights.
The American Civil Liberties Union and other advocacy groups have warned that these laws could cause families to “live in fear” and avoid things like going to the doctor or reporting crimes. When people feel unsafe, crime goes unreported, health problems do not get treated, and trust in police and other services drops.
The Political Debate
Ron DeSantis’s push for these laws comes as immigration remains a top issue in national politics. Supporters see the governor’s measures as a strong stand for law and order. They believe Florida needs to help enforce immigration laws and not wait for federal action.
Opponents call the changes harsh and say they break with the values of fairness and opportunity. Advocates accuse state officials of “targeting” certain groups because of their immigration status or background.
These disagreements are not likely to end soon. Lawsuits from groups like the ACLU and the American Immigration Council continue. Local government leaders and police are also caught in the middle, facing pressure from both the state and their own communities.
What Happens Next?
With court cases ongoing and new laws waiting to be enforced, Florida is a real-time example of what happens when states try to shape their own immigration policies in the United States 🇺🇸.
There will likely be more legal battles over which rules can stay and which must go. The final decisions may take years and could set patterns for other states. As advocacy groups keep fighting and courts make new rulings, immigrants, employers, and all residents must stay informed.
For updates on the latest immigration policies and legal developments, you can visit the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services website, a trusted source for government policies and forms.
Conclusion: Law, People, and the Future of Inmigración in Florida
The debate over Ron DeSantis’s immigration plan is not a simple one. At its core, it touches on deeply held beliefs about fairness, safety, and who gets to decide the rules. Florida’s proposed blueprint pushes the limits of state power and forces legal experts and ordinary people alike to consider how much states should be involved in federal immigration enforcement.
As the state faces tough choices, the effects will be felt not only in courtrooms but in homes, schools, farms, and businesses across Florida. By following court rulings, paying attention to official government updates, and seeking out clear information, everyone—from policymakers to families—can better understand and respond to these big changes in inmigración.
Keeping the conversation going and respecting the rights of all people, regardless of status, will remain important as Florida—and the country—works through these challenging issues.
Aprende Hoy
SB 1718 (Sección 10) → Ley estatal que criminaliza transportar inmigrantes indocumentados a Florida, aunque solo sea trasladar un familiar.
Debido Proceso → Garantía legal de trato justo y oportunidades para defenderse antes de sufrir sanciones o deportaciones.
Expulsión Acelerada → Remoción rápida de inmigrantes sin audiencia plena ante juez, limitando defensas legales.
Autodeportación → Mecanismo en que inmigrantes optan voluntariamente por salir del país para evitar sanciones mayores.
287(g) → Acuerdo federal permitiendo que policías locales colaboren con autoridades migratorias en detención y remoción de indocumentados.
Este Artículo en Resumen
La estrategia migratoria de DeSantis exige que cada policía apoye deportaciones federales y castiga a quien no coopere. Tras bloqueos legales y advertencias económicas, aumenta el temor por derechos, separación familiar y posibles daños económicos. El desenlace dependerá de fallos judiciales, datos económicos y la respuesta comunitaria en todo Florida.
— Por VisaVerge.com
Leer más:
• Administración Trump planea eliminar hábeas corpus por inmigración ilegal
• Suiza acuerda nuevas restricciones de inmigración con la Unión Europea
• Autoridades de Florida ignoran orden de la jueza Kathleen Williams sobre ley de inmigración
• Florida amplía aplicación de la inmigración con más agentes autorizados
• Estafadores de Inmigración de EE. UU. engañan a estudiantes con visa
